[net.nlang] spelling in scrabble

rvpalliende (07/13/82)

In scrabble you not only have to decide in advance what is and
what isn't a valid word (for example, by having a dictionary
whose authority will be law) but also a given word must be
known by the one who uses it. The temptation ov inventing new
words is bigger in boggle.
And even though I claim that "color", "colour", and "culer" are one
and the same word, I would allow only one spelling when playing
scrabble or boggle (preferably "color")
Anyway, these games are more "letter games" than "word games". (Maybe
you can learn some spelling while playing scrabble, but I doubt you
can learn any vocabulary)

rlr (07/14/82)

After all the smoke has cleared, something is a word if it is (or was at some
time----then it is an 'archaic' or 'obsolete' word usage) used by a significant
number of people.  If rvpalliende can get 2,000,000 or more to use 'ov' and
'culer' (hopefully over a large area, so as not to be a localized 'dialect'),
THEN these may become acceptable usages of those words.  Given that I believe
in freedom of expression, anyone is free to say (and spell) anything anyway
they want.  Acceptable usage of a word in a language(!!!!) involves a
significant portion of the people using that language understanding what the
speaker (speller) is saying.  'Ov' might indeed be understood by vast number
-s of people; it might even catch on as an acceptable spelling of the word
*if enough people use it*!!!!!!  But until then IT IS NOT AN ACCEPTABLE
SPELLING OF THE WORD THAT IS SPELLED 'of'!!!!!!!  More power to you, rvp,
in using that spelling, and good luck if you intend to spread its usage
(I wouldn't use it on my resume if I were you, if indeed I wanted to obtain
work from some employer who had never seen such usage).  But don't think you
are using a correct spelling of the word 'of'.  (But 'culer'????????  Try and
find ONE person who understands what word you are trying to use when you write
'culer'!!!!!  This is what makes a word a word----people understanding what
you say.  Otherwise everything a one-year-old says when s/he really means
something, even if noone else understands it, is a word.)
Enough already.				Rich pyuxjj!rlr