[net.nlang] pooh-pooh

riddle@ut-sally.UUCP (Prentiss Riddle) (03/20/85)

> > pooh'-pooh'  A reduplication of pooh.
> > 
> > pooh'-pooh', or pooh'pooh' the'o.ry  The theory that language orginated in
> > 	interjections which gradually acquired meaning.  Cf. BOWWOW THEORY,
> > 	DINGDONG THEORY
> 
	In some areas of publishing, it can be difficult to prove that
> someone is copying your work.  Often publishers producing things like
> maps, or dictionaries will put bogus entries into the work. ...  I believe
> you have stumbled across one of these tracer-tags.

To which I say: pooh!  :-)

Seriously, I think both definitions are legitimate.

"Reduplication" is a process of great importance in some languages and not
at all unusual in English whereby a word is doubled, sometimes with no
specific change in meaning.  Look elswhere in the same dictionary and you'll
probably find the entry:

	bye'-bye'   A reduplication of bye.

As for the second definition, there was once a family of theories of the
origin of language with intentionally comical names.  Although I doubt that
any of the theories was ever seriously believed to tell the whole story,
they all had something going for them as partial explanations as to how
language may have begun.  The "ding-dong" theory, for instance, held that
language was original onomotopoeic, i.e., the original words imitated the
objects or processes they denoted ("ding-dong" or something like it being
the word for a bell).  The "yo-heave-ho" theory claimed that language
originated as grunts made in the course of bodily exertion.  I don't recall
having heard of the "pooh-pooh" theory, but it certainly fits in with the
others.  Take a look at any old-fashioned textbook on introductory
linguistics and you'll find some of these theories mentioned.

--- Prentiss Riddle ("Aprendiz de todo, maestro de nada.")
--- {ihnp4,harvard,seismo,gatech,ctvax}!ut-sally!riddle
--- riddle@ut-sally.UUCP, riddle@ut-sally.ARPA, riddle%zotz@ut-sally

suze@terak.UUCP (Suzanne Barnett) (03/22/85)

> > > pooh'-pooh'  A reduplication of pooh.

> "Reduplication" is a process of great importance in some languages and not

Just for fun ...

Webster's 9th Collegiate (I know, it's awful, but it's right
here, right now :-) ) defines the prefix "re-" as ":again :anew"

It defines duplication as "copying or repeating" (this is what
it boils down to after it sends you to look up duplicate)

so,
re + duplication = again copying

which obviously means there must be three or more, right :-) !!
(original, first copy, reduplicated (3rd+) copy)

I guess reduplication joins the ranks of words that don't mean
what they say.

*****************************************************************
It is left to the connoisseur to check the dictionary meaning.
-- 
Suzanne Barnett

uucp:	 ...{decvax,hao,ihnp4,seismo}!noao!terak!suze
phone:	 602 998 4800
us mail: Terak Corporation, 14151 N 76th street, Scottsdale, AZ 85260