[net.nlang] "Thanks in advance" considered rude

ccrrick@ucdavis.UUCP (Rick Heli) (03/19/86)

The "Thanks in advance (TIA)" tag doesn't bother me at all.  What
does bother me more is the thought of all manner of time and money
being expended for a mere thank-you note.  To me, saying "thanks in
advance" is also an expression of how appreciative you would be were
this to be done; if the person can't or won't fulfill your request,
fine, no harm done.

ingrid@pilchuckDataio.UUCP (the Real Swede) (03/25/86)

> Although Usenet has developed a number of characteristics I think are
> helpful and appropriate to inter-computer communications, one which I find
> offensive is the oft-seen "Thanks in advance" at the end of requests for
> information or help.  This strikes me as rude -- it implies "I don't
> really care enough to send you a separate note of thanks if you help me."
> 
> Is it time to discourage this "net convention" or am I the only one who feels
> this way?
> -- 
> Ed Nather

I dunno about the rest of the folks out there, but I use that phrase when
posting an article because our outgoing mail doesn't (98% of the time) work
worth a darn.....:-) So there-you have one other opinion.
ingrid

jeanette@randvax.UUCP (Jeanette Haritan) (03/26/86)

In article <537@utastro.UUCP> nather@utastro.UUCP (Ed Nather) writes:
>Although Usenet has developed a number of characteristics I think are
>helpful and appropriate to inter-computer communications, one which I find
>offensive is the oft-seen "Thanks in advance" at the end of requests for
>information or help.  This strikes me as rude -- it implies "I don't
>really care enough to send you a separate note of thanks if you help me."
>
Thanks in advance, as far as I'm concerned, simply means "Thank you for
the effort in which you are about to make".  It doesn't necessarily mean
a separate acknowledgement of thanks will not be sent.  It could be a
more *public* "thank you", as any follow-ups are usually more appropriate
by private mail.
-- 

    ****   ****
   ****** ******
  *      *      *
 *       *       *
 *               *
  *  jeannette  *
   *           *
    *         *
     **     **
      *** ***
       *****
	***
	 *