[hacknews] explicit login to go away?

henry (08/25/82)

I am currently considering one change that has been suggested several
times in the past:  making the explicit "login" command go away.  This
would make it impossible to sign on under a new name except by signing
off first.  One could still acquire another name's permissions temporarily
using "su name".  The motive for the change is that ill-informed people
persist in using login as if it were su -- invoking it from inside the
editor and suchlike.  This does not work right and cannot be made to
work right;  the basic definition of "signing on" simply does not allow
having more than one login at a time on a single terminal.  It is a bug
that the system permits this to happen.  Unfortunately, it is pretty
much impossible to fix this without outlawing the legitimate practice
of typing "login joe" to simultaneously sign off and sign back on again
as joe.  If I find a way around this, I'll do it.  On the assumption
that I can't, does anybody have strong opinions about being unable to
type "login joe"?