[comp.sys.3b1] mailx problems - anyone seen these?

mhw@fithp (Marc Weinstein) (06/14/91)

I'm having a number of problems with mailx, originally received from
THE STORE!.

First, there are times when I'll receive a number of mail messages
from different systems, yet the display of messages (from the 'h'
command) will show some messages coming from the wrong systems.  I
think it happens only with two consecutive messages - mailx will show
both messages as coming from the sender of the first message.  The
Subject displayed is always correct, though.  I think it's especially
sensitive to smail-type messages, where the message header contains
multiple reply fields (eg - both a From: field and a Reply-To: field).

The second problem is coupled with heavy I/O activity on a tty.  When
typing my mail messages, characters, or entire lines, can be lost and
don't show up in the message - it's as if I never typed them, yet they
showed up on the screen as I was typing.  For instance, if I'm receiving
netnews batches on my tty, even at 2400 baud, I'll notice I made a mistake
in my mail message and I'll do a ~v to enter vi.  To my shock and surprise,
half the message I typed in has disappeared - lines are truncated, etc.
It's as if mailx had gone to sleep and ignored half my input.

Has anyone seen these problems?

-- 
Marc Weinstein
{simon,royko,tellab5}!linac!fithp!mhw		Elmhurst, IL
-or- {internet host}!linac.fnal.gov!fithp!mhw

tkacik@kyzyl.mi.org (Tom Tkacik) (06/16/91)

In article <1991Jun13.233136.9742@fithp>, mhw@fithp (Marc Weinstein) writes:
> I'm having a number of problems with mailx, originally received from
> THE STORE!.
> 
> First, there are times when I'll receive a number of mail messages
> from different systems, yet the display of messages (from the 'h'
> command) will show some messages coming from the wrong systems.  I
> think it happens only with two consecutive messages - mailx will show
> both messages as coming from the sender of the first message.  The
> Subject displayed is always correct, though.  I think it's especially
> sensitive to smail-type messages, where the message header contains
> multiple reply fields (eg - both a From: field and a Reply-To: field).

I have seen this more often than I would like.  It seems to me that it
happens when one message does not have a subject line.  For some reason
that message is said to come from the same person as the message before
it.  It is definitely a bug.  I got used to it when I realized that
without the source, there was nothing I could do about it.

I will take unsupported free software with source before unsupported
software without source anyday.  (I continue to use mailx because I am
used to /usr/ucb/mail, and mailx seems to be a clone of that.)

> The second problem is coupled with heavy I/O activity on a tty.  When

I have not seen this problem yet.


I have a question of my own.  When replying to a message, mailx will
insert the current message indented (with a tab).
I would like to use the standard '> ' to precede each line of an
inserted message.  Does anybody know if this can be done?

-- 
Tom Tkacik                |
tkacik@kyzyl.mi.org       |     To rent this space, call 1-800-555-QUIP.
tkacik@hobbes.cs.gmr.com  |

clewis@ferret.ocunix.on.ca (Chris Lewis) (06/17/91)

In article <1991Jun13.233136.9742@fithp> mhw@fithp (Marc Weinstein) writes:
>I'm having a number of problems with mailx, originally received from
>THE STORE!.

We tried it for a while, and had a lot of problems with core-dumping.
Can't remember the details.  We've been using mush for several years now
and have very few (if any) problems.  None serious.  Further, the
non-curses mode is enough like Berkeley Mail/AT&T mailx that people
use to them won't have any trouble.
-- 
Chris Lewis, Phone: (613) 832-0541, Domain: clewis@ferret.ocunix.on.ca
UUCP: ...!cunews!latour!ecicrl!clewis; Ferret Mailing List:
ferret-request@eci386; Psroff (not Adobe Transcript) enquiries:
psroff-request@eci386 or Canada 416-832-0541.  Psroff 3.0 in c.s.u soon!