wbp@gnv.ifas.ufl.edu (PEEL, WILLIAM B) (05/31/91)
Although I don't currently own one, I am impressed by the Redding scales, and would probably buy one if I were replacing my RCBS 10-10. The Redding #1 has been an accuracy standard for years, although slow to use since it isn't dampened. The Redding #2 is magnetically dampened, and would be slightly less accurate IN THEORY, but it is doubtful that you would be able to tell any difference without exhaustive testing. In general, look for a scale that has large notches on the beam, to prevent your poises from "skipping" to a different setting. As to differences between the major manufacturers, keep in mind that most scales are not made by the reloading companies, but are contracted out through Ohaus Company. Even Dillion's excellent scale is made by Ohaus. As to most scales being accurate to within .1 grain, don't believe it. That kind of accuracy in a mass production item is rare and would be prohibitively expensive to maintain that kind of quality control. Finally, avoid the Lee scale. I had one and found that it was difficult to use (convenience-wise) with a powder trickler, had no provision for adjustment (unless you call shimming the base with business cards adjustment), and was cheaply constructed. Hope this help, Bill Peel