[comp.sys.amiga.misc] CDTV disc caddy

kdarling@hobbes.catt.ncsu.edu (Kevin Darling) (04/13/91)

cleland@sdbio2.ucsd.edu (Thomas Cleland) writes:
> [someone wrote]:
>>Oh, one other curious note: CDTV does not have an electronic motor-driven
>>eject of the disc and its "caddy". It has a mechanical pushbutton next
>>to the CD slot. For a thousand dollar unit I was kind of surprised at
>>this.  PUsh that button too briskly and the caddy comes flying out the
>>slot and onto the floor.
>
>I wondered why that cartridge deal was there in the first place,
>rather than a regular CD-player style drawer.  I was told that 
>the cartridge system adheres to the CD-I standard, such as it 
>is, presumably with intent to make CDTV compatible with CD-I
>whenever the latter should see fit to exist.  
>
>Is this true?  What say the Wise Ones?

Well, I also first replied that caddies were standard for CDROM drives.
Seems that's not always the case.  From an email from a CD-I developer:

  "BTW the evil CD sleeve cases are NOT a CD-I standard as someone stated
   on the NET.  The reason the sleeves have shown up on CD-I players is
   all players thus far have been industrial things.  Meant for use in
   industrial settings. In that context, the sleeves make sense.

   For home use they would be a real pain. It takes about 3 hands to
   open/close them. The consumer player will have a standard slide tray,
   just like a CD player."

Sorry for the temporary confusion.  - kev <kdarling@catt.ncsu.edu>