c506634@umcvmb.missouri.edu (Eric Edwards) (05/22/91)
In article <4538@bnr-rsc.UUCP> mascot@bnr.ca (Scott Mason) writes: > poster, but I don't think it does. I wish that questions such as: > > Which is the best/cheapest/fastest... HD controller for my AXXXX? > > would be directed to CSA.marketplace, not CSA.hardware. I would like > to see CSA.hardware reserved to issues of HW design. When the > mandate for .marketplace was composed, didn't it include the above > family of questions? When the marketplace charter was composed it was a real pain becuase of grey areas like this. 1/2 :-) The lines are: If it is just pricing or availability it belongs only in marketplace. If it is just technical details it belongs only in hardware. Performace and reliability could conceivably be apropriate for both. However, followups tend to be on technical details. To avoid unecessary cross posting, the original posting should probably go into hardware. Real vague questions like the above should probably not be posted at all as they could be taken care of in a FAQ posting. Unfortunately, we don't have one. :-( In the mean time, a posting to .introduction with an email reply would probably be the best route. What ever happened to the plan to periodically repost the charters? To the best of my knowledge, the marketplace charter hasen't seen the light of day since the group was formed. Eric Edwards: c506634 @ "I say we take off and nuke the entire site Inet: umcvmb.missouri.edu from orbit. It's the only way to be sure." Bitnet: umcvmb.bitnet -- Sigourney Weaver, _Aliens_
ppalmer@oskar.uchicago.edu (Patrick Palmer) (05/22/91)
In article <c506634.3321@umcvmb.missouri.edu> c506634@umcvmb.missouri.edu (Eric Edwards) writes: >In article <4538@bnr-rsc.UUCP> mascot@bnr.ca (Scott Mason) writes: >> poster, but I don't think it does. I wish that questions such as: >> >> Which is the best/cheapest/fastest... HD controller for my AXXXX? >> > >Real vague questions like the above should probably not be posted at all as >they could be taken care of in a FAQ posting. Unfortunately, we don't have Wait a minute, did you guys read the first posting? It was not vague, and it was not about which was best..., it was about making something work. It turns out that subject has been commented on by a number of people in the last few months, and the current consensus seems to be is that it is not easy. Some A1000's can be modified to work and some seem to resist all attempts. Input from people not afraid to take things apart, unsolder chips, etc. is needed. (I only read Scott's posting because I hoped for some additional info on this subject - sorry for butting in. I tried to send email to Scott, but it bounced.) Pat Palmer (email: ppalmer@oskar.uchicago.edu)