[comp.org.eff.talk] Ownership of files

dbarberi@rodan.acs.syr.edu (05/04/91)

Hello Netlanders,

    My question is thus:
	What should the laws of 'file ownership' be?  Can a file
	in your home computer or directory be considered personal property?

	A hypothetical situation:  A user is found to have a dir full
	of unix /etc/passwd files from many other systems.  Are the passwd
	files the sole property of whatever site it is from?  Or are they
	the property of the user since they are in his directory?


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
David Barberi             |  "Support the Electronic Frontier Foundation!"   |
Syracuse University       |--------------------------------------------------|
S.I. Newhouse School of   |  Bitnet: Dbarberi@SUNRISE                        |
Public Communications     |  Internet: Dbarberi@Rodan.acs.syr.edu            | 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

jkp@cs.HUT.FI (Jyrki Kuoppala) (05/05/91)

In article <1991May4.043306.3647@rodan.acs.syr.edu>, dbarberi@rodan writes:
>	What should the laws of 'file ownership' be?  Can a file
>	in your home computer or directory be considered personal property?

I sure hope information can not be considered property, but
unfortunately at least some US courts (or is it prosecutors ?) seem to
think differently.

For more information and discussion on this, see March 1991
Communications of the ACM.  There's an article handling just this
question, can information be considered property, and also many other
articles which probably are valuable to EFF readers.

//Jyrki