[comp.protocols.time.ntp] ntp-test or xntp?

mosemann@hoss.unl.edu (Russell Mosemann) (01/23/91)

   I have just pulled some information off of louie.udel.edu (thanks,
guys!).  There were two tar files which contain ntp source, ntp-test and
xntp.  The documentation with xntp indicates that it is version 2.  I
couldn't seem to find any version indication for ntp-test.
   Which ntp should I use?  We will be setting up a SPARC2 as a
campus-wide time server.  We will not have a reference clock, so we will
be accessing the stratum 1 and 2 servers as the documentation suggests.
Thanks ahead of time for your help.
--
Russell Mosemann                  Internet:      mosemann@crcvms.unl.edu
Network Analyst                   Bitnet:               mosemann@unlvax1
Computing Resource Center         UUCP:   ..!uunet!hoss.unl.edu!mosemann
University of Nebraska - Lincoln  Voice:  (402) 472-5930   Fax: 472-5280

ellozy@FARBER.HARVARD.EDU (Mohamed Ellozy) (01/23/91)

xntpd is a later product, implementing the full Version 2 spec.  Plain
ntpd is a Version 1 product with many (most?) version 2 features implemented.
I am not sure I care, but I run xntpd as I believe in having the latest
and greatest.

xntpd has a host of programming features to ensure full accuracy, not sure
how much it matters to those who want to be within a tenth of a second or
better of teh truth.  As a consequence it is large.

xntpd has code tp prevent "excessive" switching from one server to another.
I have not looked at the code but I suspect that it sticks for too long to
a server that has drifted from the consensus.  We are talking of a drift
of twenty or so milliseconds.

Unfortunately nobody is working on a UNIX implementation of Version 3,
which seems to have large algorithmic improvements.

Summary:  Toss a coin.

Mohamed

dah@zoot.avgrp.cr.rok.com (Dave Haverkamp) (01/26/91)

    Does someone have a current list of the timeservers that are available
on the net?  In particular, are they running ntp or xntp?  My ntpd is not
syncronizing to servers it used to...  It could be a problem with our 
domain nameserver also.  But I would like to know if it is time to update
to xntp.

Thanks.

-- 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
David A. Haverkamp                    Collins Commercial Avionics Division
                                      Rockwell International   MS 124-211
INTERNET: dah@zoot.avgrp.cr.rok.com   Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52498