[net.followup] net replies vs. mail

sibley (01/25/83)

It has been (again) suggested that readers use mail more, and submit fewer
essentially identical remarks to the net.  I agree with this, but there
are problems.

Unfortunately, the "From:" field of an article need not be a valid mail
path.  There are sites that forward news but not mail.  In some cases,
this operates so that there are sites on the net that cannot be mailed to
at all, even though they send and receive news.  For example, I don't know
how to get mail from here to seismo -- the only connections I know of
involve news links through harpo, which does not (or at least for a while
did not) forward mail.  Also there used to be one-way news links.
I don't know how these handled mail, or whether they still exist.
Finally, it seems that some sites don't notify you if your mail is not
delivered, so you never know whether your message got there.

Having being burned by this problem a few times, I'm reluctant to use
remote mail to strange sites at all.

Dave Sibley
Department of Mathematics
Penn State University
psuvax!sibley