[net.ham-radio] Butternut SC3000 scanner antenna: user comments

parnass@ihu1h.UUCP (Bob Parnass, AJ9S) (11/10/85)

x
     I recently	installed a Butternut SC3000 tri-band  scan-
     ner antenna on the	chimney	of my ranch house.  The	ham-
     fest price	was about $50, $10 lower than prices  adver-
     tised in the radio	magazines.

     This is my	first outdoor scanner antenna since 1976, so
     it	 seems like I can hear "everything" with the SC3000,
     compared with the indoor antennas to which	 I've  grown
     accustomed.

     It's difficult  to	 evaluate  the	performance  of	 the
     SC3000,  having  just  moved  to  this location and few
     other antennas installed yet for comparison.   On	VHF-
     Hi, the SC3000 equals, or exceeds,	a 2 meter Cush Craft
     Ringo (not	the  Ranger)  mounted  3  feet	lower.	 I'm
     pleased  with  the	 Butternut's  UHF performance, often
     hearing the  county  sheriff's  cars  on  the  repeater
     input.

     I've a few	gripes with the	SC3000:

	- The main vertical element  is	 insulated  from  DC
	  ground,  posing  a  potential	lightning hazard.  I
	  worry	about this, and	keep the station end of	 the
	  RG8/U	 coaxial cable shorted to ground when not in
	  use.

	- Assembly  was	 hampered  by  a  scant,  one	page
	  instruction sheet.  It was impossible	to place one
	  of the tuning	pieces at the exact position  called
	  for  in the instructions, and	the poor fit between
	  two other pieces required  improvisation  using  a
	  shim.	 No technical discussion is provided, so the
	  theory behind	this unusual antenna remains a	mys-
	  tery.

	- I had	trouble	mounting the SC3000.  It's  supposed
	  to mount over	a 1" pipe or inside a conventional 1
	  1/4 inch tv mast, but	it just	wouldn't fit  inside
	  any  of  the	three  1  1/4 inch Radio Shack steel
	  masts	I tried.  No brackets or U-bolts are  provi-
	  ded,	so  I  had  to	obtain a set of	U-bolts, and
	  mount	the antenna in an unorthodox fashion.

	- Even though the SC3000 is spec'd at unity gain for
	  VHF-lo,  the	19" radial system is really for	VHF-
	  hi, so I don't expect	very  good  results  on	 the
	  30-50	MHz range.

     Being an agricultural area, the terrain is	flat in	this
     county,  and  the winds get quite brisk.  The SC3000 is
     rather frail compared to a	Ringo or Hustler G6-144, and
     dances around in the gusts, but has remained intact for
     2 months now.

-- 
===============================================================================
Bob Parnass,  Bell Telephone Laboratories - ihnp4!ihu1h!parnass - (312)979-5414