[comp.sys.ibm.pc.misc] Dos 5.0 Upgrade-Exploding the Myths

tedm@agora.rain.com (Ted Mittelstaedt) (06/23/91)

Well, it has not yet been a week and a half and there are already a huge number
of false ideas swirling around DOS 5.0.  After having read the manual, and
installed it on a '286 & 386SX I would like to answer some questions that are
being obviously asked by those who have not yet bought the distribution pkg.
  
1) MS-DOS & IBM-DOS are different prices at Egghead, and it is better to run
one or the other on different machines.
  
  This is a myth.  As most people know by know, Egghead Software is currently
  offering the DOS 5.0 upgrade for $39.95.  BOTH MS-DOS 5.0 and PC-DOS 5.0 
  are included in this price, as stated numerous places in EGGHEAD flyers.
  In addition, although some people have said to only run IBM-DOS 5.0 on IBM
  machines, This is only true for machines having old ROMS.  I have sucessfully
  run MS-DOS 3.3 on True Blue IBM PC's having roms dated October '82 and
  Microsoft themselves has stated in numerous press releases that "This DOS
  is the most compatible DOS release so far"  The idea that MS-DOS 5.0 will not
  run on IBM boxes is silly.  The only possible reason someone would want to
  buy IBM-DOS instead of MS-DOS is if they had a true blue under a service
  contract or something specifying only to cover the machine under IBM programs.

2) "I have a '286 with 384K extended memory, and therefore DOS 5.0 will not run
   in extended memory."

  Here is another myth.  When installed on a '286 with 384K of extended memory,
  DOS 5.0 will place itself in the HMA, or the first 64K of memory starting
  at the 1 meg border.  The rest of the extended memory can be used for 
  something useful such as SMARTDRV.SYS's disk cache.

3) I cannot load device drivers into Upper Memory Blocks with a '286.

  Another myth.  Microsoft specifically states that EMM386.sys will not run
  on a '286, however they continue on to state that any UMB memory manager
  that works with HIMEM.SYS will allow programs to run in UMB's. If you have
  a 286 with a memory card that can be configured to backfill the upper memory
  area (the unused portions that is) there is no reason why you cannot use
  the DEVICEHIGH & LOADHIGH commands in your config.sys & autoexec.bat to
  place programs there.

4) The Upgrade package does not contain all the dos that the "Full Distribution
   package" does.

  This is the saddest lie to hit the industry so far.  The only think lacking
  from the upgrade package is a boot disk.  However COMMAND.COM, IO.SYS, 
  and MSDOS.SYS are the only 3 files needed to make a boot disk, and these
  3 files are included in the distribution disk.  The only people to benifit
  from this nonsense are vendors like Zenith who make their money off of
  selling licensed versions of the supposed "Full Distribution Release"

5) The new ANSI.SYS in DOS 5.0 is an upgraded version of the ansi.sys in 4.01

  This is the biggest, fattest lie so far.  There is a bug in some EGA cards
  that will lose the cursor when some software packages put the screen in
  43 line mode.  Microsoft fixed this bug by placing the Locked option in
  ANSI.SYS, released in DOS 4.01.  Unfortunately for EGA owners, the so-called
  new and imporved ANSI.SYS in DOS 5.0 does not support the /L option.
  However, it is possible to get around this by using the SETVER command in 
  DOS 5.0 and setting ANSI.SYS to version 4.00

tedm@agora.rain.com