mcg@joevax.UUCP (Mark Germain) (01/01/86)
In the January,86 issue of QST, the ICOM IC-735 HF transceiver was
'reviewed' in their Product Review section. Specifically designed
for mobile/portable operation, QST's 'review' of the IC-735 failed
to address substantive issues, even the most fundamental
mobile/portable-specific operational features of the IC-735 which
either enhance or degrade it's application to this unique subset
of amateur radio.
For the past four years I have been using an IC-720A, in a dedicated
mobile environment, which, at the time it was purchased, was considered
to be the 'top-of-the-line' of the ICOM offerings. In practice, however,
even the most basic features, such as adequate undistorted audio output,
or even more importantly, an effective noise blanker for the mobile
environment, were not, in my opinion, considered adequately in the design
of this transceiver. A thorough product review would have provided at
least substantive guidelines so that in its application to a particular
operating environment, a knowledgeble choice could be made.
I am once again searching for another HF transceiver for dedicated mobile
operation. If anyone can identify a sound product review with substantive
information, addressing the noise blanker, selectivity, and certainly,
mobile ergometrics, I would greatly appreciate your effort.
Mark, KB2IF