[comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware] 386sx chip

baer@uwovax.uwo.ca (07/26/90)

I was recently told by a systems hardware salesperson (trying to
push 386 DX systems over 386 SX systems) that there are software 
compatibility issues for 32-bit software and SX-based systems.
He implied that OS/2 2.0 will probably not run on an SX, and 32-bit
applications most certainly will not, because of the memory addressing
limitations of the SX (he said that software developers *could* rewrite
32-bit applications to make them run on the SX, but software designed 
for DX-based systems could crash on SX systems.  Could anyone provide
information on this issue?   I understood the 386sx chip to be completely
compatible (except for slower memory addressing due to the 16-bit path),
but is there a limitation around the amount of memory the SX is capable
of addressing, or how it addresses this memory?



---------------------------------------------------------------------
Douglas Baer,  Dept. of Sociology,
University of Western Ontario, London, Canada N6A 5C2
Internet: BAER@UWO.CA    Bitnet: BAER@UWOVAX

mlord@bwdls58.bnr.ca (Mark Lord) (07/27/90)

In article <6533.26ae1cf6@uwovax.uwo.ca< baer@uwovax.uwo.ca writes:
<I was recently told by a systems hardware salesperson (trying to
<push 386 DX systems over 386 SX systems) that there are software 
<compatibility issues for 32-bit software and SX-based systems.
<He implied that OS/2 2.0 will probably not run on an SX, and 32-bit
<applications most certainly will not, because of the memory addressing
<limitations of the SX (he said that software developers *could* rewrite
<32-bit applications to make them run on the SX, but software designed 
<for DX-based systems could crash on SX systems.  Could anyone provide

A big crock of potent hooved mammal excretions.

It is almost impossible for software to even tell the difference between
the two processors.  I have yet to hear of a program which does, although
I do have an idea of how to go about it (I'm not telling, though).

It ain't easy for software to distinguish at all, since, except for speed,
they are 100% identical.  And speed varies depending on other system 
characteristics, so that is not a reliable indicator at all (my 386sx is
faster than a lot of 16-mhz 386dx machines).

In hardware, sure, so we can't connect as many megabytes of memory to
the 386sx as to a 386dx.. big deal.  By the time I can afford that much
memory, It'll be time to upgrade to the cheap 486's anyway (since the 586
will likely exist by then, pushing down prices).

-- 
 ___Mark S. Lord__________________________________________
| ..uunet!bnrgate!bmerh614!mlord | Climb Free Or Die (NH) |
| ..uunet!bnrgate!mlord%bmerh614 | Personal views only.   |
|________________________________|________________________|