[comp.sys.mac.comm] Liaison 3.0 initial impressions.

pascal@CAM.ORG (Pascal Gosselin) (11/16/90)

To all of those who have patiently waited for Farallon's release of
version 3.0 of Liaison, the wait is finally over.  I received my upgrade
today and was luckily able to trash the very crash-prone Apple Internet
Router.

Installation:

Things didn't go as smoothly as planned.  Liaison 3.0 doesn't work properly
with the Emac Speedlink v2.5 driver when EtherTalk is selected as the
"home port".  The home port is the port on which the Appletalk services
of the Mac running the router is located.  The solution proposed by Tech
Support was to relocate the home port on the LocatTalk port.  This cured
the freeze-up problem at startup without sacrificing speed.  I will be
shipping them a copy of the driver for analysis tomorrow (the problem
occurs with an SE, I haven't had the time to try other CPUs yet).

All ports run at full speed!

Yes, this is a great feature of version 3.0. The home port is purely
cosmetical, no routing is required from any zone that is physically
connected to the router (when accessing AppleTalk services on the router
Mac).

Security still weak:

I was expecting to see some kind of Packet-level security to hide
LaserWriters, Mail servers, File Servers, etc...  The press release claimed
"new" security features.  I haven't found any.  The only thing you can do
is to completely hide one zone from another (quite useless).


AppleTalk Phase II support (finally!) with a bit of confusion:

The Phase II support seems to work fine, this is great news to those like
myself who use EtherTalk cards that require AppleTalk version 53 to be
installed in order to work properly.  This caused havoc under Liasion 2.0.6.
The biggest flaw is the installation process, which fails to distinguish
between Phase I and II drivers upon setup.  It is a minor hassle noted
on a release sheet, but it bugs me a bit!


CCL support:

Sounds great but I haven't used it yet.


Conclusion:

I just hope that it is more reliable that Apple's AIR, which has been
one huge headache for me in the past 2 months (constant crashing of
our AppleShare file server).  Only time will tell !!!


-- 
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Pascal Gosselin          | Internet: Pascal@cam.org   Applelink: CDA0585   |
| Gest-Mac Inc. Apple VAR  |   Voice (514) 767-4444   Fax (514) 767-7337     |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+