[comp.sys.mac.system] Seagate Hard Disk

MacIIfx@drsmbx.uucp (Pat Wallach) (06/30/90)

Hy there everybody.

Does somenone know which problems st- 138 n Hard Disks have ?

Sometimes when I turn on my mac the hard disk doesn't come ?


Thanks. cu :-)

PAt

n138ct@tamuts.tamu.edu (Brent Burton) (07/06/90)

I've owned a Seagate drive for about 19 months.  In December of 1988, I
bought a ST-277N drive.  I built a "homebrew" drive.  It workd fine
for about three weeks, then the drive would not start up when turned on.
I called HDI (I bought it from them) and they replaced the drive in like
a week or so.  This second drive lasted through January of this year. It
started doing the same things- no spin up, grinding noises .... I called
Seagate and told them (not in the nicest way I know) that for the price
I paid for one of their drives, I should be getting more than one year
out of them.  They fixed it -- I had to ship it to Florida via the 
expensive shippers, they fixed it in "28 days" (6 weeks) and I paid
$210.  One person told me it was $230 or so, but the other charged me
the $210 (better).
   Once I got the rebuilt drive, I reassembled it, and been _extremely_
careful with it.  I did not abuse the old mechanisms in _any_ way; they
just didn't last.  This rebuilt mechanism has a different bearing on it
than it used to.  I heard the grease in the drives' bearings may become
gummy, and if the drive is off for a while, the grease cools and sticks.
   I've had no problems with my rebuilt unit; I let run all the time.

   I do know I'll never buy another Seagate drive again.
Brent Burton
n138ct@tamuts.tamu.edu
BPB9204@TAMSTAR.BITNET

Adam.Frix@p2.f200.n226.z1.FIDONET.ORG (Adam Frix) (07/07/90)

> 
> Does somenone know which problems st- 138 n Hard Disks have ?
> 
> Sometimes when I turn on my mac the hard disk doesn't come ?


High humidity seems to be one condition which causes this for me.  I'm ready
to trash the drive and get a good one, but it's the boss's, and he's too cheap
to do that, so he's figured that if he puts the SE on its face (screen down)
and turns the machine on, that'll get it going _almost_ every time.

And yes, I have full backups.  :-)

--Adam--


--  
Adam Frix via cmhGate - Net 226 fido<=>uucp gateway Col, OH
UUCP: ...!osu-cis!n8emr!cmhgate!200.2!Adam.Frix
INET: Adam.Frix@p2.f200.n226.z1.FIDONET.ORG

pdel@ADS.COM (Peter Delevoryas) (07/10/90)

>> Does somenone know which problems st- 138 n Hard Disks have ?
> I'm ready to trash the drive and get a good one

I haven't heard too much praise for Seagates. Would it be better
to buy a quantum than to try and get my Seagate repaired? It would
be $210 to fix, but maybe this is throwing good money after bad.
I need a 40-80 mb drive.


Peter D.