[net.cse] The Great Educational Debate

wbpesch@ihuxp.UUCP (Walt Pesch) (04/14/84)

An example is the reason behind the almost universally prevalent
requisite of the one year of geometry.  Though vary few of us ever use
it, it has all taught us the basis of mathematical logic.  It is for
this vary reason that many schools right now have been replacing the
standard year of geometry with computer science programs teaching the
kids programming.



                          Still waiting for the bolt from the skies,

                                          Walt Pesch
                                      AT&T Technologies
                                     ihnp4!ihuxp!wbpesch

mauney@ncsu.UUCP (Jon Mauney) (04/16/84)

>	An example is the reason behind the almost universally prevalent
>	requisite of the one year of geometry.  Though vary few of us ever use
>	it, it has all taught us the basis of mathematical logic.  It is for
>	this vary reason that many schools right now have been replacing the
>	standard year of geometry with computer science programs teaching the
>	kids programming.

I don't want to start a debate over math education,  but I must protest
this maligning of geometry!  Many's the time I have wondered over some
minor problem until I realize that I learned the answer in tenth grade.
And I must say that the Euclidean model is an excellent approximation of
the real world for my purposes.  Take a poll of the readers of
net.rec.build-things-with-your-hands and see how many use geometry.
Why, just yesterday I was walking down one of the hallowed halls here and
overheard two students discussing a problem in computer graphics;  one was
explaining to the other, with a slight touch of wonder in his voice,
"and apparently, if you know two angles and one of the sides, that completely
determines the rest of the triangle!"

Now,  ask me how often I use my knowledge of differential calculus.

-- 


_Doctor_                           Jon Mauney,    mcnc!ncsu!mauney
\__Mu__/                           North Carolina State University