[net.followup] Caffeine: Birth Defects and More

crane@fortune.UUCP (11/03/83)

Thank you for the information. 

There are are probably a lot of people who would counter these
arguments by saying that they really enjoy coffee and that it hasn't
hurt them and they have been drinking it for umpteen years. Fine, let
them continue using it. I don't think anybody could convince them
otherwise, and it's not worth the effort to try.

But, I wonder how many people drink coffee simply out of habit without
any idea of its potentially harmful effects.  Or how about people who
drink it simply because there is nothing else around to drink. It seems
to me that employers could be a lot more concerned about providing
alternative drinks in the workplace.

debenedi@yale-com.UUCP (Robert DeBenedictis) (11/15/83)

A recent article concerning caffeine had the
following information.
    DRINKS         MILLIGRAMS PER 12 OZ.
    Coke           65
    Tab            50
    Pepsi          43
    Mountain Dew   55
These facts do not jive with those in an issue of
Consumers Report from about 20 months ago. 
Particularly, coke was rated as having ~34 mg. and
pepsi was rated as having ~37 mg.

"Now, You're Never Alone"
Another Message In The Bottle from
Robert DeBenedictis

fulk@sunybcs.UUCP (Mark Fulk) (11/17/83)

The original article on caffeine suggested drinking herbal teas as
a substitute during pregnancy.  People who saw that article should
be warned that many herbal teas contain teratogens (birth-defect
producing substances) that are much more powerful than caffeine.
In particular, one should carefully avoid teas containing
chamomile, ginseng, spearmint, and wintergreen.  It would probably
be a good idea to avoid any tea claiming medicinal effects as
those effects are provided by powerful, ill-characterized drugs
in the tea; there has never been a careful study of the teratogenic
potential of herbs so caution is advisable.  My wife is pregnant now;
she not only avoids coffee, tea, and soda (and has greatly reduced
her chocolate intake); she also avoids all herbal teas and honey
(which has also been implicated in birth defects - not from the glucose,
but from the impurities).  When she wants a hot drink she drinks
hot apple cider (sweet, not hard) or hot water.  She accepts that
when she's tired, she should sleep, and doesn't try to artifically
alter her mood.  I'm so glad she being so careful, that I follow the
same rules myself most of the time, and I haven't felt better in years!

Incidentally, the world is full of restrictive advice for pregnant women;
it is very difficult for a woman to remain happy while avoiding various
foods, drinks, and delicacies if her spouse/friend/significant other/co-parent
is whooping it up at the bar or otherwise enjoying things she has forgone.
Husbands/co-parents should observe the same restrictions their wives/etc.
do just for solidarity.
-- 
Mark Fulk				Department of Computer Science
fulk.buffalo@udel-relay			SUNY at Buffalo
...!rocksvax!sunybcs!fulk		4226 Ridge Lea Rd.
(716)831-3061				Amherst, NY  14226