[comp.sys.apple2] GS System Software Complaint

jordan@hpfcdj.HP.COM (Steve J. Jordan) (05/22/91)

Recently, someone else commented that one of their biggest complaints about 
GS system software was that text was black on a white background.  That
comment seemed to be ignored, so I thought I'd re-surface the complaint.
The white background of GS windows annoys me almost to the point I can't
stand using them!

I don't know alot about GS programming, but is this problem something that
should be fixed in the GS system software--or is it simply that
all GS programmers have been following a standard & the system software is not
at fault?

I suppose the problem could be remedied either by reversing things to make the
text white and the background black, or by making things user-selectable.

Is there someone out there at Apple that might listen to my complaint?

Steve Jordan
jordan@hpfcdj.hp.com

giovin@medr0.ecs.umass.edu (Rocky J Giovinazzo) (05/23/91)

In article <29110019@hpfcdj.HP.COM> jordan@hpfcdj.HP.COM (Steve J. Jordan) writes:
>Recently, someone else commented that one of their biggest complaints about 
>GS system software was that text was black on a white background.  That
>comment seemed to be ignored, so I thought I'd re-surface the complaint.
>The white background of GS windows annoys me almost to the point I can't
>stand using them!
	Actually, bright backgrounds with dark text is better for your
eyes than the reverse.  Maybe a beige background would be better, but
I'd be against going to black.

Rocky Giovinazzo

nagendra@bucsf.bu.edu (nagendra mishr) (05/23/91)

I agree, but I end up using inverter which is an NDA which reverses
all the colors.

But shouldn't this be a control panel option? Something that the user
sets?

nagendra

nagendra@bucsf.bu.edu

MQUINN@UTCVM.BITNET (05/23/91)

On Tue, 21 May 91 21:49:09 GMT Steve J. Jordan said:
>Recently, someone else commented that one of their biggest complaints about
>GS system software was that text was black on a white background.  That
>comment seemed to be ignored, so I thought I'd re-surface the complaint.
>The white background of GS windows annoys me almost to the point I can't
>stand using them!
>
>I don't know alot about GS programming, but is this problem something that
>should be fixed in the GS system software--or is it simply that
>all GS programmers have been following a standard & the system software is not
>at fault?

It's mostly the System Softwares' fault.  Although, programmers can make their
programs with white text on a black background... it's really a function of
the system software.  Snowterm and the Sonic Blaster software are the only
programs I've seen that allow you to change the colors to whatever you like.
Except, in Snowterm, you're forced to have a blinding, distracting, white
menu bar on top.  Other than that, Snowterm is great.

>I suppose the problem could be remedied either by reversing things to make the
>text white and the background black, or by making things user-selectable.

There's an NDA out called Inverter, but it's sorta buggy and some applications
don't like it at all (Appleworks GS) and it's a little flaky in others.  What
we need is a control panel device, similar to the macs' which lets us define
our own desktop colors.  Those colors are then saved, and ALL applications are
affected by the new change.  One problem with the one on the mac is you can't
change the black and white colors.  If we had this CDEV on the GS, but had
access to ALL the colors, most importantly, black and white, this would make
the GS EMENSELY more enjoyable for myself, and I'm sure, MANY others.

How 'bout it, Apple System Software Dudes (or Dudettes)?  :)

>Is there someone out there at Apple that might listen to my complaint?
>
>Steve Jordan
>jordan@hpfcdj.hp.com

----------------------------------------
  BITNET--  mquinn@utcvm    <------------send files here
  pro-line-- mquinn@pro-gsplus.cts.com

MQUINN@UTCVM.BITNET (05/23/91)

On Wed, 22 May 91 17:18:46 GMT <info-apple-request@APPLE.COM> said:

>	Actually, bright backgrounds with dark text is better for your
>eyes than the reverse.  Maybe a beige background would be better, but
>I'd be against going to black.

How 'bout having it user selectible?  I don't like the idea of someone else
deciding what's best for me (not implying that you're doing that, and that
wasn't directed to you either, so don't take affense, please).

>Rocky Giovinazzo

----------------------------------------
  BITNET--  mquinn@utcvm    <------------send files here
  pro-line-- mquinn@pro-gsplus.cts.com

dlyons@Apple.COM (David A Lyons) (05/23/91)

In article <29110019@hpfcdj.HP.COM> jordan@hpfcdj.HP.COM (Steve J. Jordan) writes:
>Recently, someone else commented that one of their biggest complaints about 
>GS system software was that text was black on a white background.  That
>comment seemed to be ignored, so I thought I'd re-surface the complaint.
>The white background of GS windows annoys me almost to the point I can't
>stand using them!
>[...]
>Is there someone out there at Apple that might listen to my complaint?

I hear you, but the most workable solution I can think of involves swapping
black and white in the color table, and I hear there is an NDA out there
that does this.  (I've also heard it crashes under some applications?  Don't
know why, it's a simple enough thing to do.)

So far inclined *not* to try to make the system software swap the colors
this way, because it would make some applications look really bad, through
no fault of their developers.

Most people seem happy with white backgrounds, so maybe a third-party NDA
is a good solution.
-- 
David A. Lyons, Apple Computer, Inc.      |   DAL Systems
Apple II System Software Engineer         |   P.O. Box 875
America Online: Dave Lyons                |   Cupertino, CA 95015-0875
GEnie:DAVE.LYONS  CompuServe:72177,3233 Internet:dlyons@apple.com

My opinions are my own, not Apple's.

charlie@pro-mansion.cts.com (Charles Vangsgard) (05/24/91)

In-Reply-To: message from dlyons@Apple.COM

Perhaps the black on white complaint comes from someone who is accustomed
to using a PC.  We like the familiar.  If someone handed me a news paper
which was interely black with white lettering I would say ICKY! Would we
want to watch our TV sets with a black background and white lettering?  It
is no wonder the PC and Mac users are so different, they consider the other
side to be using INVERSE VIDEO.
----
ProLine:  charlie@pro-mansion
Internet: charlie@pro-mansion
UUCP:     crash!pro-mansion!charlie
ARPA:     crash!pro-mansion!charlie@nosc.mil

MQUINN@UTCVM.BITNET (05/25/91)

On Fri, 24 May 91 11:16:08 GMT Charles Vangsgard said:
>In-Reply-To: message from dlyons@Apple.COM
>
>Perhaps the black on white complaint comes from someone who is accustomed
>to using a PC.  We like the familiar.  If someone handed me a news paper
>which was interely black with white lettering I would say ICKY! Would we
>want to watch our TV sets with a black background and white lettering?  It
>is no wonder the PC and Mac users are so different, they consider the other
>side to be using INVERSE VIDEO.

hehehe... Actually, I'm used to white text on black backgrounds for being
around Apple II's for so long.  When the GS came out with the desktop, I
couldn't stand it (I couldn't stand the -desktop-, not talking abut the GS).
But you're right.  It seems like inverse video to me.  I remember, LONG before
the GS came out, I patched DOS 3.3 to print in inverse (black text on a white
background) and thought it was the most god-awful thing I'd ever seen.  When
the GS came out with that exact same thing, I was really amazed that some one
would actually make an operating system like that.  It's just the WORST I
could possibly imagine .... well, I guess a puke greenish-brown background
with pail-green text COULD be worse....:)

As for the newspaper & T.V... I'd rather read white text with a black back-
ground on T.V.  and I've actually thought about this before, but I think
that black paper with white text would look really cool, but when you're
talking about reflective light (light reflecting off paper) and additive
light (light emitting from a picture tube) it always looks best for additive
to have light text and dark background (for me).  I can't express how much
I hate the white background.  It's just utterly disgusting.

-------------------
By the way... about that GUIMaster... Someone e-mailed it to me (thanks, by
the way), It crashes when I select the NDA from the finder.  I wrote my
own 'module', but I can't figure out how to keep it from using those
home-made radio dials, scroll bars, etc...  They look really bad in 320 mode.
Also, I can't figure out how to make white text with a black background.
The documentation just says, it's in the toolbox reference.

It would be EXTREMELY nice if we have an 'official' CDEV from Apple that
we could rely on and use easily.  Not everyone has APW or ORCA (which is
required for GUImaster.

Don't get me wrong about GUImaster though... it's pretty nice, just a little
buggy and pretty hard to use, AND I really appreciate it being e-mailed
to me.

>----
>ProLine:  charlie@pro-mansion
>Internet: charlie@pro-mansion
>UUCP:     crash!pro-mansion!charlie
>ARPA:     crash!pro-mansion!charlie@nosc.mil

----------------------------------------
  BITNET--  mquinn@utcvm    <------------send files here
  pro-line-- mquinn@pro-gsplus.cts.com

dkl@xcluud.sccsi.com (David Leikam) (05/26/91)

  [ Stuff re changing desktop/windows to white-on-black omitted]
 
  While we're on the general topic of changes to the desktop defaults.. is 
there a good (i.e, works, doesn't crash) way to change the system font from 
Shaston to something else of my choice?  There was a utility that could do 
this on the Mac (Can't remember the name of it).  Any reasonable way to do 
it for the //GS?  (Yes, I know about looking over the results carefully, and 
the spacing problems, &c. I'll be careful.)

geniusman@pro-hindugods.cts.com (Chris Moylan) (05/29/91)

In-Reply-To: message from dkl@xcluud.sccsi.com

There is MenuFont NDA.  I don't know where it cam from, but it is on the
Hindu Love Gods ProLine BBS at 313/644-0481 in MI.  Real short d/l time.

Chris
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chris Moylan
ProLine:  geniusman@pro-hindugods
Internet: geniusman@pro-hindugods.cts.com
UUCP:     crash!pro-hindugods!geniusman
ARPA:     crash!pro-hindugods!geniusman@nosc.mil
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

mattd@Apple.COM (Matt Deatherage) (05/31/91)

In article <qD7i34w164w@xcluud.sccsi.com> dkl@xcluud.sccsi.com (David Leikam) writes:
>
>  While we're on the general topic of changes to the desktop defaults.. is 
>there a good (i.e, works, doesn't crash) way to change the system font from 
>Shaston to something else of my choice?  There was a utility that could do 
>this on the Mac (Can't remember the name of it).  Any reasonable way to do 
>it for the //GS?  (Yes, I know about looking over the results carefully, and 
>the spacing problems, &c. I'll be careful.)

Well, it's possible, but it's not very prevalent for two reasons:

1)  Some applications have hard-coded the menu bar height for Shaston 8, making
    other fonts less than desirable.

2)  The toolbox has a circularity problem with changing the system font.  The
    Window, Menu and Control Managers all use the currently installed System
    font for their work, but if you want to get a new system font off disk,
    you usually want to use the Font Manager -- which has to be started
    _after_ the WCM trio.  To make the WCM tools use a new system font, you'd
    have to shut them down and restart them, which is marginally safe if you
    have other tools depending on them (like TextEdit) and is totally unsafe
    if you're a DA or other non-application.

    But generically speaking, the conceptual solution is easy:  You just have
    to make the font you want the system font before starting up the desktop
    tools.  You just can't usually use the Font Manager to help.  <sigh>
-- 
============================================================================
Matt Deatherage, Developer Technical  | The opinions expressed herein are
Support, Apple Computer, Inc.         | not those of Apple Computer, and
Personal mail only, please.  Thanks.  | shame on you for thinking otherwise.
^^^^^^^^ Technical questions are not personal. Please post them instead.
============================================================================

unknown@ucscb.UCSC.EDU (The Unknown User) (05/31/91)

In article <53499@apple.Apple.COM> mattd@Apple.COM (Matt Deatherage) writes:
>    But generically speaking, the conceptual solution is easy:  You just have
>    to make the font you want the system font before starting up the desktop
>    tools.  You just can't usually use the Font Manager to help.  <sigh>

	Can you change the system font that will be used on the NEXT 
boot?

	I don't know what makes something the "system font" or not, but 
if it's possible to make some sort of program that lets you select the 
system font, but only operates upon the next boot, it seems the problem is
solved.

	Lots of Mac programs only act on changes you've made after the
next boot.
-- 
/unknown@ucscb.ucsc.edu       Apple IIGS Forever!        unknown@cats.ucsc.edu\
|WANT to help get ULTIMA VI //e or GS written?-mail me. CHEAP CD info-mail me.|
\                    It's a Late Night World.... Of Love                     /

mattd@Apple.COM (Matt Deatherage) (06/03/91)

In article <16381@darkstar.ucsc.edu> unknown@ucscb.UCSC.EDU (The Unknown User) writes:
>
>	Can you change the system font that will be used on the NEXT 
>boot?
>
>/unknown@ucscb.ucsc.edu       Apple IIGS Forever!        unknown@cats.ucsc.edu\
It's not a matter of booting, it's a matter of starting QuickDraw.  You could
conceivably load the font (via the Font Manager), copy the handle so the
Font Manager wouldn't dispose of it on FMShutDown and thereby keep it around -
but you'd also have to patch QDStartUp to call SetSysFont with that font
handle again.  QuickDraw defaults to a Shaston 8 (well, actually a ROM) system
font every time it's started up.

-- 
============================================================================
Matt Deatherage, Developer Technical  | The opinions expressed herein are
Support, Apple Computer, Inc.         | not those of Apple Computer, and
Personal mail only, please.  Thanks.  | shame on you for thinking otherwise.
^^^^^^^^ Technical questions are not personal. Please post them instead.
============================================================================