[comp.sys.amiga.hardware] A3000 hard drive capacity

lesle@NCoast.ORG (David A. Lesle) (05/20/91)

What is the larges (preferably reasonable fast as well) hard drive
that can fit in the drive bays of an A3000?  So far the highest
capacity drive I've found that I know will fit is the Quantum 210M
unit.  Any others larger?
-- 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
David Lesle                uucp: ncoast!lesle
CLEVELAND AREA-AMIGA USERS' GROUP (CA-AUG)     (216) 642-3344 (BBS)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

elg@elgamy.RAIDERNET.COM (Eric Lee Green) (05/22/91)

From article <1991May20.102326.27503@NCoast.ORG>, by lesle@NCoast.ORG (David A. Lesle):
>
> What is the larges (preferably reasonable fast as well) hard drive
> that can fit in the drive bays of an A3000?  So far the highest

Maxtor has a 320mb 3 1/2" drive, around $1400 from D.C. Drives (see latest
Computer Shopper). I hear that there are larger 3 1/2" drives available,
but haven't seen one advertised, probably because they're too new.

Of course, if you REALLY want size+speed, get a Fujitsu 1.2gig in an
external case... has a 5 year warranty, too! (And a price to match.)

--
Eric Lee Green   (318) 984-1820  P.O. Box 92191  Lafayette, LA 70509
elg@elgamy.RAIDERNET.COM               uunet!mjbtn!raider!elgamy!elg

peic@core.north.de (Peter Eichler) (05/22/91)

In article <1991May20.102326.27503@NCoast.ORG>, David A. Lesle writes:

>
>What is the larges (preferably reasonable fast as well) hard drive
>that can fit in the drive bays of an A3000?  So far the highest
>capacity drive I've found that I know will fit is the Quantum 210M
>unit.  Any others larger?

Well, you can use internally every SCSI 3.5" hard disk . Dunno wether
Quantum has bigger ones but try to get a look on other company's
price list. I think, this will help.

Cheerio,
Peter

logan@netxcom.netx.com (Jim Logan) (05/25/91)

In article <1991May20.102326.27503@NCoast.ORG> lesle@NCoast.ORG (David A. Lesle) writes:
# 
# What is the larges (preferably reasonable fast as well) hard drive
# that can fit in the drive bays of an A3000?  So far the highest
# capacity drive I've found that I know will fit is the Quantum 210M
# unit.  Any others larger?

I have a MaxStor 340MB.  The only problem is that the A3000's ROMs
get impatient waiting for the drive to wind up and I have to do a warm
reboot when it gives me the 2.x floppy/HD and 1.3 floppy/HD menu.

It's a 12ms drive.  That's faster than the Amiga-supplied 100MB and
200MB drives that come in the 3000UXB and 3000UXD.

			-Jim
-- 
Jim Logan                Home: uunet!gimlet!logan
Consultant               Work: logan@netx.com
Net Express, Inc.       Phone: (703) 749-2269

FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) (05/25/91)

At a rough guess I would say that about 350Meg is the limit for a 3.5"
drive (right now anyway).  Definitely less than 500 Meg.  Micropolis
is shipping the largest 5.25" drive right now, about 2.0 Gig.  I don't
know what the capacities are in *"and larger drives.  I don't think 
any of them are SCSI.  

I've got another question (to keep you gurus on your toes :->).  SCSI
has a block address limit of about 1.2 Gig for 512 Byte blocks.  If I
buy a 2.0 Gig drive and partition the drive into at least two logical
drives, do I avoid this problem?  This is a serious question.  I ordered
a SPARC 2 with a pair of 2.0 Gig drives for work and I'm not sure what
will happen when we format them.  So enlighten me O gurus.

Dana Bourgeois @ cup.portal.com

johnhlee@CS.Cornell.EDU (John H. Lee) (05/29/91)

In article <42674@cup.portal.com> FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) writes:
[...]
>I've got another question (to keep you gurus on your toes :->).  SCSI
>has a block address limit of about 1.2 Gig for 512 Byte blocks.  If I
>buy a 2.0 Gig drive and partition the drive into at least two logical
>drives, do I avoid this problem?  This is a serious question.  I ordered
>a SPARC 2 with a pair of 2.0 Gig drives for work and I'm not sure what
>will happen when we format them.  So enlighten me O gurus.

The problem is that some disk drivers use the non-extended SCSI commands
for block address over 1.2Gb (21 bits address for a 512 byte block) and
inadvertantly "wrap-around" and access the lower blocks.  This is not
an inherit bug in the SCSI drives or protocol, but a bug in the disk
drivers.  (NOTE:  "extended" SCSI commands do not mean "non-standard",
just that they have more bits for block addresses and other things.)

The drive does nothing with regard to partitioning; only the system
software cares about this.  Partitioning the drive will ensure you don't
access blocks over 1.2Gb, but the faulty drivers still can't access
partitions containing blocks at locations over 1.2Gb.  In other words,
you can still only use 1.2Gb of the 2.0Gb drive.

You should ask your disk-driver software vendor.  As far as I know, this
problem cropped up on DEC VMS and Ultrix disk-drivers, and should be fixed
by now.  I don't know if SPARCstation SunOS disk-drivers have the same
problem.  I believe that the AmigaDOS 2.0 scsi.device also had this problem
but that it is now also fixed.  Fujitsu was recommending you treat 2.0Gb
drives as 1.2Gb drives until you receive corrected drivers.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The DiskDoctor threatens the crew!  Next time on AmigaDos: The Next Generation.
	John Lee		Internet: johnhlee@cs.cornell.edu
The above opinions are those of the user, and not of this machine.

jesup@cbmvax.commodore.com (Randell Jesup) (05/29/91)

In article <42674@cup.portal.com> FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) writes:
>At a rough guess I would say that about 350Meg is the limit for a 3.5"
>drive (right now anyway).  Definitely less than 500 Meg.

	It's about 500 Meg now (quantum, seagate, others), and Micropolis
just announced a 1gig 3.5" drive for 3rd quarter.  They expect it to get down
to about $1/MB by the 2nd quarter of next year or so.  I think Fujitsu is
about even with them.

>I've got another question (to keep you gurus on your toes :->).  SCSI
>has a block address limit of about 1.2 Gig for 512 Byte blocks.

	No, common scsi drivers don't think to switch to 10-byte reads
when they pass the amount addressable with 6-byte reads.  Since Gig+ drives
have arrived, suddenly everyone is reving their drivers, including Dec.

>  If I
>buy a 2.0 Gig drive and partition the drive into at least two logical
>drives, do I avoid this problem?

	No.  It's not the offset to the partition, it's the offset to the
device.

>I ordered
>a SPARC 2 with a pair of 2.0 Gig drives for work and I'm not sure what
>will happen when we format them.  So enlighten me O gurus.

	Good luck.  A solution: format them as 1024 byte logical blocks.
I'm not certain that the Sun drivers/format will allow this.

-- 
Randell Jesup, Jack-of-quite-a-few-trades, Commodore Engineering.
{uunet|rutgers}!cbmvax!jesup, jesup@cbmvax.cbm.commodore.com  BIX: rjesup  
Disclaimer: Nothing I say is anything other than my personal opinion.
"No matter where you go, there you are."  - Buckaroo Banzai

mscritsm@isis.cs.du.edu (Milton Scritsmier) (05/29/91)

In article <42674@cup.portal.com> FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) writes:
>At a rough guess I would say that about 350Meg is the limit for a 3.5"
>drive (right now anyway).  Definitely less than 500 Meg.  Micropolis
>is shipping the largest 5.25" drive right now, about 2.0 Gig.  I don't
>know what the capacities are in *"and larger drives.  I don't think 
>any of them are SCSI.  
>
Actually, you can expect several 1 gig 3.5 inch drives to be announced by
the end of this year.  In fact, last week Micropolis announced a 1.2 gig
3.5 inch drive which supposedly will be sampling in the next quarter.
Others are supposed to be from Conners and Maxtor.  In addition, they also
transfer data much faster from the media, spinning at 4500 rpm or more.

ptavoly@cs.ruu.nl (Peter Tavoly) (05/29/91)

In <42674@cup.portal.com> FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) writes:

>At a rough guess I would say that about 350Meg is the limit for a 3.5"
>drive (right now anyway).  Definitely less than 500 Meg.  Micropolis
>is shipping the largest 5.25" drive right now, about 2.0 Gig.  I don't
>know what the capacities are in *"and larger drives.  I don't think 
>any of them are SCSI.  

Quantum has a 425 MB drive (I *think* that is 3,5", don't know about the
height though) on offer.

>Dana Bourgeois @ cup.portal.com

 -ThomasT.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~          ____
Thomas Tavoly, Commercial Computer Science - HEAO Utrecht, NL.           / / /
"Whoever talks too much, has no time to think." - Peter Tavoly.       AMIGA /
Favourite quote: "The Mac OS is amazingly complex,               ____  / / /
 .sig v3.0e       given how little it does." - Peter da Silva    \ \ \/ / /
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~>> ptavoly@praxis.cs.ruu.nl <<~~~~~~~~~  \_\_\/_/

darrell@comspec.uucp (Darrell Grainger) (05/29/91)

In article <1991May29.042901.27634@mnemosyne.cs.du.edu> mscritsm@isis.UUCP (Milton Scritsmier) writes:
>Actually, you can expect several 1 gig 3.5 inch drives to be announced by
>the end of this year.  In fact, last week Micropolis announced a 1.2 gig
>3.5 inch drive which supposedly will be sampling in the next quarter.
>Others are supposed to be from Conners and Maxtor.  In addition, they also
>transfer data much faster from the media, spinning at 4500 rpm or more.

How tall is this 1 gig 3.5" drive? I think the Amiga 3000 only has a 1"
clearance for the hard drive. It might be a little more but not much.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
| Darrell Grainger (darrell@comspec) |Comspec Communications Inc.    |
| Toronto, Ontario, Canada           |Disclaimer: My opinions do not |
|  (416)617-1475     (416)633-5605   |reflect those of my employer.  |
|------------------------------------+-------------------------------|
|      Motorcycle: Honda PC800       |      Computer:Amiga 2000      |
----------------------------------------------------------------------

dale@boing.UUCP (Dale Luck) (05/30/91)

In article <42674@cup.portal.com> FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) writes:
[...]
>I've got another question (to keep you gurus on your toes :->).  SCSI
>has a block address limit of about 1.2 Gig for 512 Byte blocks.
>a SPARC 2 with a pair of 2.0 Gig drives for work and I'm not sure what
>will happen when we format them.

Some drive support different block sizes, if your disk drive software can
handle 1k block sizes then you could format the drive for 1k byte blocks
and effectively get an extra address bit. When I was more of a unix hacker
years ago, that was one of the things we did to speed up unix I/O.



-- 
Dale Luck     GfxBase/Boing, Inc.
{uunet!cbmvax|pyramid}!amiga!boing!dale

mscritsm@isis.cs.du.edu (Milton Scritsmier) (05/31/91)

In article <1991May29.133329.1240@comspec.uucp> darrell@comspec.uucp (Darrell Grainger) writes:
>In article <1991May29.042901.27634@mnemosyne.cs.du.edu> mscritsm@isis.UUCP (Milton Scritsmier) writes:
>>Actually, you can expect several 1 gig 3.5 inch drives to be announced by
>>the end of this year.  In fact, last week Micropolis announced a 1.2 gig
>>3.5 inch drive which supposedly will be sampling in the next quarter.
>>Others are supposed to be from Conners and Maxtor.  In addition, they also
>>transfer data much faster from the media, spinning at 4500 rpm or more.
>
>How tall is this 1 gig 3.5" drive? I think the Amiga 3000 only has a 1"
>clearance for the hard drive. It might be a little more but not much.

I haven't seen any pics or read any descriptions of the dimensions.  Just
guessing, I would assume that they achieve that capacity in part by having
a lot of platters (say 6 to 8 or so) which means that the drive certainly
would not be a half height.  Almost certainly it will be more than an inch.

greg@pfloyd.lonestar.org (Greg Harp) (05/31/91)

>How tall is this 1 gig 3.5" drive? I think the Amiga 3000 only has a 1"
>clearance for the hard drive. It might be a little more but not much.

The A3000 will take any 'standard height' 3.5" drive.  If the 1 gig
drive is the same height as most 3.5" HD's it'll fit fine.
 
--
greg@pfloyd.lonestar.org----greg@pfloyd.UUCP----convex!egsner!pfloyd!greg
copy protection: n. A class of clever methods for preventing incompetent 
   pirates from stealing software and legitimate customers from using it.  
   Considered silly.

Reid_Bishop@a68k.UUCP (Reid Bishop) (05/31/91)

In a message dated Thu 30 May 91 23:13, Darrell@comspec.uucp (darrell Grain
wrote:

 DG> How tall is this 1 gig 3.5" drive? I think the Amiga 3000 only has a
 DG> 1"
 DG> clearance for the hard drive. It might be a little more but not much.

Indeed, you can put _two_ 1" drives stacked on top of each other inside the
Amiga 3000's drive bay.  (At least two Quantum Q105LPs.)  The drive bay(s)
will hold a standard 1/2 height 3 1/2" drive, which typically run anywhere
from 1 1/2" to 2 1/2" tall.

-- Via DLG Pro v0.97b


~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Somebody's gotta fight for the AMIGA!! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

   Reid Bishop-  Customer Support & Programming, M.V. Micro

   UUCP:  boulder!tcr!a68k!Reid_Bishop          [Reid Bishop]

   FIDO:  (1:104/224)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

tope@enea.se (Tommy Petersson) (05/31/91)

In article <42674@cup.portal.com> FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) writes:
-At a rough guess I would say that about 350Meg is the limit for a 3.5"
-drive (right now anyway).  Definitely less than 500 Meg.  Micropolis
-
-Dana Bourgeois @ cup.portal.com

Fujitsu say that they will be shipping a 520MB (unformatted, I beleive)
3.5" drive in September. I don't know how reliable they are at giving
release dates...

Tommy Petersson
tope@enea.se

cazabon@hercules (Charles Cazabon (186-003-526)) (05/31/91)

In article <greg.0469@pfloyd.lonestar.org> greg@pfloyd.lonestar.org (Greg Harp) writes:
:>How tall is this 1 gig 3.5" drive? I think the Amiga 3000 only has a 1"
:>clearance for the hard drive. It might be a little more but not much.
:
:The A3000 will take any 'standard height' 3.5" drive.  If the 1 gig
:drive is the same height as most 3.5" HD's it'll fit fine.
: 
The A3000 will not take a standard height drive.  It will only accept a half
height drive.  However, I have yet to see a 3.5", full height drive.
A point of semantics, but best to be clear about it...


--Chuck Cazabon, cazabon@hercules.cc.uregina.ca
* My Opinions Are Not My Own...Feel Free To Plagiarize 

billsey@agora.UUCP (Bill Seymour) (06/02/91)

In article <42674@cup.portal.com>, Dana B Bourgeois writes:

> At a rough guess I would say that about 350Meg is the limit for a 3.5"
> drive (right now anyway).  Definitely less than 500 Meg.  Micropolis
> is shipping the largest 5.25" drive right now, about 2.0 Gig.  I don't
> know what the capacities are in *"and larger drives.  I don't think 
> any of them are SCSI.  

	there are half a dozen or so manufacturers that are shipping at
least evaluation quantities of >500M 3.5 inch drives.  Most of them are
very fast, and most are inexpensive when looked at as a $/MByte cost...

> Dana Bourgeois @ cup.portal.com

  -Bill Seymour     nesbbx!billsey@agora.uucp or nesbbx!billsey@agora.rain.com
*****   American People/Link  Amiga Zone Hardware Specialist   NES*BILL  *****
Bejed, Inc.     NES, Inc.        NAG BBS         NES BBX BBS    Home Sometimes
(503)281-8153   (503)246-9311   (503)656-7393   (503)640-9337   (503) 640-0842

FelineGrace@cup.portal.com (Dana B Bourgeois) (06/04/91)

Recently Reid Bishop Posted:

RB>In a message dated Thu 30 May 91 23:13, Darrell@comspec.uucp (darrell Grain
RB>wrote:

  DG> How tall is this 1 gig 3.5" drive? I think the Amiga 3000 only has a
  DG> 1"
  DG> clearance for the hard drive. It might be a little more but not much.

RB>Indeed, you can put _two_ 1" drives stacked on top of each other inside the
RB>Amiga 3000's drive bay.  (At least two Quantum Q105LPs.)  The drive bay(s)
RB>will hold a standard 1/2 height 3 1/2" drive, which typically run anywhere
RB>from 1 1/2" to 2 1/2" tall.

RB>   Reid Bishop-  Customer Support & Programming, M.V. Micro
RB>   UUCP:  boulder!tcr!a68k!Reid_Bishop          [Reid Bishop]
RB>   FIDO:  (1:104/224)

Now I could be wrong about this (Really! It's possible!), but I
thought the 'standard' 3.5" drive was the same height as a half-height
5.25" one.  And that the 'half-height' 3.5" drive is not always 
half the height of the half-height 5.25" ones one should be
careful about making assumptions on how many devices can fit in the
drive bays.  Seagate calls them 'low profile' 3.5" drives.  I have a
catalog at work and can quote dimensions if anyone is interested.  

Dana Bourgeois @ cup.portal.com