[rec.audio.high-end] LP12 vs Axis

tom@minster.york.ac.uk (06/29/90)

Hi David,

>>Sigh. So, I'm a little stuck.  I really liked the better bass presence of the
>>Lynn LP12, so if it really was mostly attributable to the deck, I may have
>>to bite the bullet and get the used LP12, _if_ I can talk it down to $600.
>>On the other hand, I could wait around until a used Axis shows up, but I've
>>been looking for a while, and haven't seen any


Personally speaking, I would go for the used LP12 over an Axis or Linn Basik.
The dealer was right - it was the LP12 deck that was responsible for the better
bass response.  A seven year old Linn LP12 with all the upgrades should be in
a perfectly good condition (theres' very little to wear after all, and the LP12
bearing is very high quality).  The turntable is primarily responsible for the
quality of the reproduction - the arm and cartridge are passive components - the
deck drives them.

Stretch to the LP12 if at all possible - you will appreciate the differences
all the more after having lived with a good deck.  A very important point is
that while it may financially stretch you a little now, it will stand you in
a much better position to upgrade in the long term. The Axis (Basik ?) will
not really support a much better arm than the Basik that comes with it,
so if you ever want to upgrade you'd end up having to sell the whole deck.

Regarding surface noise - I've found this very much a cartridge dependent thing.
Some cartridges are better than others in this respect.  I recently put an
Audio technica OC9 into my Pink Triangle deck and was stunned at how quiet
the background noise was - it was almost eery between passages - as close to
CD silence as I've ever heard. 

Hope that's some help.

tom.

____________________________________________________________
 Tom Jackson, Advanced Computer Architecture Group,
 Dept. of Computer Science, University of York, Heslingto      3 n,
 YORK. YO1 5DD.  UK.               Tel: [044] (0904) 433747

bjanes@ral.rpi.edu (Atle Bjanes) (07/02/90)

In article 509, >From: tom@minster.york.ac.uk, I read the following:

>>>Sigh. So, I'm a little stuck.  I really liked the better bass presence
>>>of the Lynn LP12, so if it really was mostly attributable to the deck,
>>>I may have to bite the bullet and get the used LP12, _if_ I can talk
>>>it down to $600.  On the other hand, I could wait around until a used
>>>Axis shows up, but I've been looking for a while, and haven't seen any


>Personally speaking, I would go for the used LP12 over an Axis or Linn
>Basik.  The dealer was right - it was the LP12 deck that was
>responsible for the better bass response.  A seven year old Linn LP12
>with all the upgrades should be in a perfectly good condition (theres'
>very little to wear after all, and the LP12 bearing is very high
>quality).  The turntable is primarily responsible for the quality of
>the reproduction - the arm and cartridge are passive components - the
>deck drives them.

I own a Linn LP-12 that is approximately 12 years old.  I use a Dynavector 
DV-505 arm with a Dynavector 23D MC cartridge.  I am very pleased with the
performance of this setup and the deck has served me well for many years.

However, if I understand the above article correctly, LP-12 may be updated
to become even better.  Would anyone out there tell me about these updates.
I would be very interested in recommendations.  I will post a summary on the
net if I receive anything interesting.

Atle Bjanes

bjanes@ral.rpi.edu