[rec.audio.high-end] girl talk -- REVIEW

lrb@rrivax.rri.uwo.ca (Lance R. Bailey) (11/20/90)

[ _girl_talk_, The Holly Cole Trio, Alert Music Inc, Z2-81016, DDD ]
[ content: 5 ,performence: 10 ,recording: 9  (max: 5,10,10) ]

I am very happily listening, for about the 10th time in 3 days, this latest
disk from this Toronto jazz group.

The HCT has been around for a few years, I first heard them on a New Music
interview about a year ago, they've made a big hit in Toronto, and have
travelled from New York to the Yukon offering the very intimate type of
jazz that seems to be making a strong come back.

Holly is a visual treat, she melts into her role dressing in 'revival'
clothes on stage and _being_ a jazz vocalist from the smoky bars of
prohibition.  But although Holly seems to be born of the wrong decade, she
is no anachronism, she takes her greatest delight in revamping the lyrics
of old standards to more properly meet today's mores and values.

The trio consists of Holly on vocal, Aaron Davis on piano and David Piltch
on string bass. On occasion "percussive imagination" is added by David.
Individually Holly and David are the strongest on the album, an opinion
formed by such tracks as _My_Baby_Just_Cares_For_Me_ (which is interpreted as
a vocal and string bass duet) and the bass intro to the title cut. 

Holly's vocals are sparked with emotion. While she handles such classics as
_My_Baby_ or _Love_For_Sale_ (the latter unfortunately left off this pressing)
with ease, the additional material, varying from _I'm_So_Lonely_I_Could_Cry_
to _Downtown_ all get the same heart-felt treatment and somehow do not
seem out of place beside the others. Holly can laugh at us during _girl_talk_
or cry with us during _Spring_Can_Really_Hang_You_Up_The_Most_.

David's string bass work is flawless, the solo in _My_Baby_ has quickly 
become my favourite bass work, usurping Jay Leonhart's Salamander Pie [Digital
Music Products]. The finger work is well defined and he knows when to yank
on the strings and when to just pluck and when to just stroke.

Additional sax work by John Johnson and trumpet by John Macleod is added on
the cuts _Cruising_ and  _I'm_So_Lonely_ respectivley. Both artists mesh in
well with the trio, and Johnson's breathwork hints at real greatness.

The liner notes explain that producer Peter Moore attempted to mimic Billie
Holiday's sessions by grouping the trio around the single Calrec Ambisonic
Microphone and recording live to two track (machine not noted).

The effect of this recording technique produces an excellent feel of 
intimacy. Holly is centre soundstage, David behind by about 2 feet and right
by 3 feet. Aaron's piano tucks in nicely behind Holly and just left of
centre. I am a little disapointed that nothing really comes forward of the
speakers, not as it does with the recordings of Mari by Three Blind Mice,
or the Cybill Sheppard lps I have.  This however does not mean that the
soundstage is distored, it matches the film/video that I saw of the recording
sessions, it just happens to be placed a little further back than i prefer.

Other than that minor comment, the recording is truly quite impressive. The
detailing on the string bass and resonance of the wood is clearly heard. 
During the solo work, you can hear Piltch softly grunt and gasp with the
effort of trying to make the bass do what he is feeling. The piano work comes
through crisp and lacking the muddiness that can really mess it up. The
trumpet work, even with straight mute, sounds -- to this ex-trumpet player --
true to life, with none of that tinny, squawking that can haunt poor trumpet
playing.


The big advantage to living in the Canada (other than a manical appreciation
of summer) is that we hear not only the majority of U.S. distributed artists, 
but gems such as this recording from here in Canada. Look for it.


lance


Lance R. Bailey, Systems Manager 
================================   box: Robarts Research Institute
email: lrb@rri.uwo.ca                   Clinical Trials Resources Group
  fax: 519.663.3789                     P.O. Box 5015, 100 Perth Dr.
  vox: 519.663.3787 ext. 4108           London, Canada N6A 5K8