[bit.listserv.history] stalin III

OCONNOKR@LEMOYNE (02/13/90)

Thanks for thoughtful comments regarding the question as to why many
more people do not know about Stalin's atrocities.

One answer was that it was not directed aainst one identifiable group.
In the case of the Holocaust--the atrocities were directed against specific
groups--but what about the Ukraine and the forced starvations?


Kieran OConnor

oconnokr@lemoyne

KATHY@GACVAX1 (Kathy Morrison) (02/14/90)

Mr. O'Connor asked a reasonable question regarding estimates of the
numbers killed by Stalin's government and by the Turks.  He was given
what I thought were reasonable answers aand books were suggested for
further information.  Then he used, and continues to use, the list's
time to ask why these millios were killed and why nobody knows about it.

While I do not wish to send flames directly to Mr. O'Connor, his
questions are a perfect example of my complaint.  I understood this
list to be a discussion among people not only interested in but
knowledgeable about history.  I wish folks would spend a little study time
of their own rather than asking others to do their work for them.  In
that way the tone of the list is raised substantially.  For example, if
Mr. O'Connor would skim the books suggested his questions would lose
their naive flavor and the rest of us might not only find the discussion
more interesting but we all might learn something.

I find Mr. Cerny's responses endlessly patient.  Thank you for the good
example and I apologize for not following it.

Kathy Morrison
13 February l990