[bit.listserv.novell] Seagate ST4096 problems in servers

RIDDLE@SUVM.BITNET (Bruce L.Riddle (315) 443-9057) (02/28/90)

I have four Seagate 4096 drives running in file servers.  One has been
running for over 3 years without a bip in a PC/AT. I
never turn them off; I try and keep them at a reasonable
constant temperature.

ABTSACS@UWLAX.BITNET (Dan Abts - UWL System/Network Manager) (02/28/90)

A year ago I was considering Seagate 4096 drives for 5 of our servers since
it was a fairly large drive supported by our old Zenith 248 setup.  Our
local computer store that supports many Novell networks recommended against
it.  He said the 4096 drives either fail during compsurf or within a short
time compared with some other brands.  I bought 72mb CDC drives and they have
been great.

Over the past 6 years I have had 1 four year old 40mb CDC drive fail in a
server.  Four Seagate 40mb drives have failed.  They generally don't last a
year.  I always replace them with CDC drives.  I will not put another Seagate
drive in a server.  I have had two Micro Science 40mb drives running for
two years without problems.

                                                Dan Abts
                                                Academic Computing Services
                                                Univ. of WI - La Crosse
                                                ABTSACS@UWLAX.EDU
                                                ABTSACS@UWLAX.BITNET