[bionet.molbio.genome-program] Human Genome research Re: JITF II Minutes

sgoldste@CISE.NSF.GOV (Steve Goldstein--Ph 202-357-9717) (02/12/91)

Dear colleagues,

Referencing the following paragraph from your report:

"The Connectivity and Infrastructure Working Group reported that its aim
is to foster capability and not to mandate what is done or how.  It
recognizes, however, that currently Internet is the standard for
connectivity in the U.S.  The working group recommended that all
genome centers and genome data resources should be Internet accessible
and that the funding agencies should provide guidance and support for
these connections.  The group pointed out that the availability of
these resources on the network would create a second cycle of demand
from individual researchers (not resources or centers) who need access
to the resources.  The NIH and DOE should be aware of this demand and
prepared to provide for it.  Finally, the group urged the NIH to join
the Internet consortium.  There is anecdotal evidence that NIH-funded
chers have been refused network connections on
Internet-connected campuses and given the reason that their research
is not funded by an Internet-member agency.  [Editor's note: John
Wooley, NSF, assures me that that is not a valid reason: the Internet
agreement requires all connected campuses to "work with" all
researchers on campus to provide them with Internet connections.  The
term "work with" has been subject to a variety of interpretations at
various institutions.]  Dr. Lipman pointed out that DHHS is "one of
the players" in the High Performance Computing Initiative and that the
NLM is the DHHS representative at the HPCI discussions.  The JITFF
asked that the topic of connectivity be put on the agenda for the next
meeting."

The NSFNET is available for all research and scholarly activity performed
at or in support of not-for-profit research and academic institutions.
Funding by an Internet-member agency is not a criterion for use.  I
believe that the NLM and the NCI are among DHHS institutions already connected
to the Internet (in this case, to the NSFNET portion of the Internet)
through the NSFNET regional network, SURANET, at the University of Maryland.
DHHS is indeed one of the players in the HPCC (final "C" for "Communications")
Initiative.  In addition, Dr. Larry Dusold of DHHS's FDA represents DHHS
on the Federal Engineering Planning Group (FEPG) which advises the
agencies which operate the federal portion of the US Internet on technical
networking matters.  Please inform your colleagues that the NSFNET, the
Energy Science Net (ESnet) and the NASA Science Internet, inter alia, as
the core of the US federal Internet, have been implemented to serve the science
and academic communities. Special commitment has been expressed for supporting
the "Grand Challenges", including the Human Genome Project.  Also, we have
built, and we are expanding, robust networking connections to Germany 
(including EMBL) and to Japan (including Kyoto University) as well as to
UK (MRC-Harrow) and to most of Europe, North America and the Pacific Rim,
all with TCP/IP access.  This is a joint (DARPA, Energy, NASA, NSF)
undertaking in cooperation with international partners who operate research
and academic networks abroad.  I will append the NSFNET [Interim] Acceptable
Use Policy  for your information.

Please let us know if there is any specific assistance we can render in
support of your work, both domestic and international.

Best regards,

Steve Goldstein

+ ======================================================================== +
||  Steven N. Goldstein                                                   ||
||  Program Director, Interagency & International Networking Coordination ||
||  Div. of Networking and Communications Research & Infrastructure       ||
||  National Science Foundation                                           ||
||  1800 G Street, N.W., Room 416                                         ||
||  Washington, D.C. 20550                                                ||
||  Tel: +1-202-357-9717                                                  ||
||  FAX: +1-202-357-0320                                                  ||
||  goldstein@NSF.GOV (Internet); goldstei@NSF (BITNET)                   ||
+ ======================================================================== +

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Interim NSFNET Acceptable Use Policy
6/14/90

The purpose of NSFNET is to support research and education in and 
among academic institutions in the U.S. by providing access to 
unique resources and the opportunity for collaborative work.

This statement represents a guide to the acceptable  use  of the 
NSFNET backbone. It is only intended to address the issue of use of 
the backbone. It is expected that the various middle level networks 
will formulate their own use policies for traffic that will not 
traverse the backbone.

(1)	All use must be consistent with the purposes of 
NSFNET.

(2)	The intent of the use policy is to make clear 
certain cases which are consistent with the purposes 
of NSFNET, not to exhaustively enumerate all such 
possible uses.

(3)	The NSF NSFNET Project Office may at any time 
make determinations that particular uses are or are 
not consistent with the purposes of NSFNET.  Such 
determinations will be reported to the NSFNET Policy 
Advisory Committee and to the user community.

(4)	If a use is consistent with the purposes of NSFNET, 
then activities in direct support of that use will be 
considered consistent with the purposes  of NSFNET.  
For example, administrative communications for the 
support infrastructure needed for research and 
instruction are acceptable.

(5)	Use in support of research or instruction at not-
for-profit institutions of research or instruction in 
the United States is acceptable.

(6)	Use for a project which is part of or supports a 
research or instruction activity for a not-for-profit 
institution of research or instruction in the United 
States is acceptable, even if any or all parties to the 
use are located or employed  elsewhere.  For example, 
communications directly between industrial 
affiliates engaged in support of a project for  such an 
institution is acceptable.

(7)	Use for commercial activities by for-profit 
institutions is generally not acceptable unless it can 
be justified under (4) above.  These should be 
reviewed on a case-by-case basis by the NSF Project 
Office.

(8)	Use for research or instruction at for-profit 
institutions may or may not be consistent with the 
purposes of NSFNET, and will be reviewed by the NSF 
Project Office on a case-by-case basis.

kristoff@genbank.bio.net (David Kristofferson) (02/13/91)

Steve,

	I think it would be helpful if you posted a note explaining to
researchers the steps they should take to get their campus connected
to the Internet, i.e., who should they contact to get the ball
rolling.  Questions like this come up all the time.

				Sincerely,

				Dave Kristofferson
				GenBank Manager

				kristoff@genbank.bio.net

kristoff@GENBANK.BIO.NET (David Kristofferson) (02/13/91)

Help! I am trapped on the list and can't get off!

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Phil

----------------------------Original message----------------------------
Steve,

        I think it would be helpful if you posted a note explaining to
researchers the steps they should take to get their campus connected
to the Internet, i.e., who should they contact to get the ball
rolling.  Questions like this come up all the time.

                                Sincerely,

                                Dave Kristofferson
                                GenBank Manager

                                kristoff@genbank.bio.net

sgoldste@CISE.NSF.GOV (Steve Goldstein--Ph 202-357-9717) (02/16/91)

Dave,

Thanks for the suggestion.  My colleagues are preparing a list of
what to do, and we shall take it as an action item.

Steve G.

     >
     >
     >Steve,
     >
     >	I think it would be helpful if you posted a note explaining to
     >researchers the steps they should take to get their campus connected
     >to the Internet, i.e., who should they contact to get the ball
     >rolling.  Questions like this come up all the time.
     >
     >				Sincerely,
     >
     >				Dave Kristofferson
     >				GenBank Manager
     >
     >				kristoff@genbank.bio.net
     >