[soc.religion.islam] History vs. Myth

ta-dw30@cunixa.cc.columbia.edu (David Worenklein) (02/12/91)

I feel like I don't contribute enough to this board; I just ask questions but, as a Jew who's sole exposure to Islam is in two classes at Columbia University,
I have more questions than answers, so...

   How important is the historic Muhammad, that is, the man who was born about
52 years before the hijra to Medina, who married Khadija, who woke up every
morning and ate breakfast like you and me, especially in contrast to the mythic
(ie larger-than-you-and-me) Muhammad, whose every word and deed can teach us
something about how man ought to act?  Am I completely missing the point?

Please reply with your opinion by Thursday 2/14 - that's when my paper is due.

Also, are the actions of Muhammad before the first revelation as important as
his actions afterwards?

					Peace among Man,
					David Worenklein

PS As always, my apologies if I offend anyone.  It is never my intention to
hurt - only to learn.