[comp.sys.mac.hardware] MacRescue vs. NewBridge, the results of my findings

6500erik@ucsbuxa.ucsb.edu (Erik Adams) (10/17/90)

Well, after many phone calls, and wading through the sparse
mail I received on the topic, here are the results of my
research:

NewBridge1 lists for $295, but I've seen it advertised for
$199.

MacRescue lists for $317, and I don't think anybody sells it
but them, or at least I can't find any ads for it in the most
recent MacUser.

Reports from the field on MacRescue were positive:  the people
at the company were extrememly helpful, installation was easy,
and in some ways the SCSI port performed better than that of a
Plus or an SE (I have a letter with some technical stuff that
I don't really understand, but that's the gist of it all).

Reports from the field on NewBridge1 were non-existant.

MacWorld ran an article earlier this year describing these  
products, but description was all they had:  no lab reports, noo
comparisons of compatibility, and so on.

The only piece of performance information I could get that
might cleave between the two of these products has to do with
making a ramdisk:  MacRescue will allow you to have installed
6 1/2 Mb of memory, using 4 as addressable RAM and the other 
2 1/2 as a ramdisk.  NewBridge1 does not.

Both companies make boards that are similar to the ones under 
consideration here, but that include a video adapter for installing
large screen monitors.  Again, they list for about the same
price, but the NewBridge2 board at that level _does_ support
making a ramdisk.

So, its kind of a coin toss:  either you can save quite a bit of
money and not be able to make a ramdisk on top of your 4 megabytes,
or you can spend $100 more and have that option.

I'll probably go with MacRescue, because I like options.

Erik
6500erik@ucsbuxa.bitnet
   <or>
6500erik@ucsbuxa.ucsb.edu