[fa.info-vax] Another disk problem with V4.0

info-vax@ucbvax.ARPA (02/16/85)

From: engvax!KVC@cit-vax

I just sent out one horror story on my VMS V4 upgrade last week, here's
another that the list oughta know about.

Does anyone else out there have 8 disk drives on one SI 9900 controller
(daisy-chained) under VMS V4?

After getting the SI patches for DRDRIVER, I ran the system after hours
under V4 for about a week.  During that time, I had no trouble with my
SI equipment (7 eagles and one rm05 look-alike) except for some intermittent
trouble with disk number 5 in the chain.  On Saturday morning, our SI
engineer found low voltages on disk number 5 and tweaked them up.  The
disk was now happy.  Saturday afternoon, we build VMS V4 on our system disk
(an RP07).  After getting the patches to DRDRIVER for the Eagles, we rebooted
the system and found that AUTOCONFIGURE only configured 6 out of 8 disks
on the controller.  This couldn't have been a software problem because we
ran after hours all week with all 8 drives under VMS V4, with the same
kludged DRDRIVER.  Must've been the work on the Eagle that morning...

Well, after checking all the cabling, we found nothing wrong.  SI suggested
I reset the controller and reboot.  This time, it only had 4 out of 8 disk
drives.  Next I tried powering the controller off and back on and rebooting.
Now I was down to 2 bloody drives on the $&*^%$*^% controller!  This trend
was not encouraging, I did not muck with the controller any more, it seemed
to be trying to tell me something...

At this point it had to be a hardware problem in the controller, so the
SI people went to work swapping boards.  That didn't seem to help.  Finally,
I got a brainstorm and decided to try booting with the regulation issue
DRDRIVER.  You cannot map the eagles correctly with it, but it will
find the devices on the controller if they are there.  Sure enough, the
system AUTOCONFIGURED 8 drives on that controller!  Rebooted with the
SI mangled driver and there were now 4 drives.  It's easy to blame the
patches, except that I'd run with them all week at night without any
trouble!

Fortunately, during this fiasco we noticed that after the system autoconfigured
however many drives it felt like configuring that time, you could run
SYSGEN and AUTOCONFIGURE that adapter again.  Each time you re-autoconfiged
it, you got another drive!  The drives were real too, you could mount them
and all the data was intact!  So, at least we have a work-around.  My
SYSTARTUP.COM now begins with the following lines:

	$ MCR SYSGEN
	AUTO 10
	AUTO 10
	AUTO 10
	AUTO 10
	AUTO 10
	AUTO 10

Looks pretty dumb, huh...

Can anyone out there explain this?  It has to be something the FE did
Saturday morning that confused the patched DRDRIVER, but not the real
DRDRIVER.  I find that awfully hard to imagine...

	/Kevin Carosso      engvax!kvc @ CIT-VAX.ARPA
	 Hughes Aircraft Co.