[comp.unix.aix] X11r4 on Xstations ... version mismatch?

pack@acd.acd.ucar.edu (Daniel Packman) (04/11/91)

I recently installed Xwindow software version 1.2 on an RS6000/530
running AIX 3.1.x002 (we still await 3.1.5).  The Xstation 120 (system
version 1.3) works fine with the default "bootfile".  According to
the README file, one can use "bootfile1" if you have enough memory
and this will allow one to run X11r4.  Going through the procedure
in the README, the system fails on bootup.  Specifically,
   bootp operates normally
   tftp  seems to download properly
then the message "unable to connect to fileserver" appears on the top
of the screen.

This problem has been reported already and the quoted solution seems to betray
a limited understanding of the problem at hand.  Don't tell me to check
the bootptab file, it already operated successfully.  Don't tell me to
check to see if tftp is enabled, it already started up.  Don't tell me
to reboot the system for no reason, it doesn't solve this problem.  Don't
tell me to see if the x_st_mgrd is running.  It is.

Is there a minimum AIX or Xstation version that is compatible with X11r4?

Dan Packman     NCAR                             INTERNET: pack@ncar.UCAR.EDU
(303) 497-1427  P.O. Box 3000                       CSNET: pack@ncar.CSNET
                Boulder, CO  80307-3000      DECNET  SPAN: 9583::PACK

jdh@bu-pub.bu.edu (Jason Heirtzler) (04/13/91)

In article <11012@ncar.ucar.edu>, pack@acd.acd.ucar.edu (Daniel Packman) writes:
|> I recently installed Xwindow software version 1.2 on an RS6000/530
|> running AIX 3.1.x002 (we still await 3.1.5).  The Xstation 120 (system
|> version 1.3) works fine with the default "bootfile".  According to
|> the README file, one can use "bootfile1" if you have enough memory
|> and this will allow one to run X11r4.  Going through the procedure
|> in the README, the system fails on bootup.  Specifically,
|>    bootp operates normally
|>    tftp  seems to download properly
|> then the message "unable to connect to fileserver" appears on the top
|> of the screen.

I have the exact same problem here with both our Xstation 120 and
Xstation 130!  When I called Austin there were three (!) different
answers:

   Some people report success with 3003
   You need to run 3004
   It's not supported until 3005

Are there any developers in Austin who can shed some light on the
true story?  This is particularly troubling since I've heard rumors
that IBM won't start volume shipments of 3005 for about a week.  The
call ID of my problem is 6X049.  Please, help me out here.

jdh

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Jason Heirtzler           (617) 353-2780       jdh@bu-pub.bu.edu
Information Technology    Boston University    ..!bu.edu!bu-pub!jdh