andrew@calvin.doc.ca (Andrew Patrick) (04/02/91)
The results are in for the proposed newsgroup comp.sources.reviewed.
The voting was closed on Sun Mar 31 1991.
A total of 324 valid votes were received (excluding duplicate votes and
one person who voted both "yes" and "no", see below).
"Yes": 270 votes
"No": 54 votes
Criterion 1: 100 more "yes" than "no" votes
270 - 54 = 216 OK
Criterion 2: at least 2/3 of the total number of votes are "yes"
270/324 = 83% OK
Therefore, comp.sources.reviewed passes and will be added as a
newsgroup. However, it is customary to have a 5-day waiting when the
votes can be verified.
Listed below are the names of the people from whom I recorded votes,
sorted into "yes" and "no" categories.
"Yes" votes:
"CONTR, HERRICK, DAN" <abvax!iccgcc.decnet.ab.com!herrickd@uunet.UU.NET>
"Christopher M. Conway" <wombat@nfinit.enet.dec.com>
"D. J. McCarthy ~" <dmccart%modl01.intel.com@RELAY.CS.NET>
"Erich Meier (Inf4 - hiwi)" <ecmeier@immd4.informatik.uni-erlangen.de>
"Jonathan I. Kamens" <jik@pit-manager.MIT.EDU>
"Karsten Nyblad, TFL, Denmark" <KARSTEN@tfl.dk>
"Mark W. Eichin" <eichin@ATHENA.MIT.EDU>
"Ralph P. Sobek" <ralph@vega.laas.fr>
"Roger H. Goun 18-Mar-1991 1242" <goun@ddif.enet.dec.com>
"Stuart L Labovitz" <valinor!stu>
"Terry Kennedy, Operations Mgr" <TERRY%SPCVXA.BITNET@qucdn.queensu.ca>
"Terry Poot" <tp@mccall.com>
"Vander Pol, Mark" <markv@elmer.hls.com>
"david d [zoo] zuhn" <zoo@aps1.spa.umn.edu>
"william b. coleman" <clmn@midway.uchicago.edu>
@polari@cs.washington.edu ( )
Alan B. Clegg <abc@concert.net>
Andrei Cogan <coganman@ocf.Berkeley.EDU>
Baruch Cochavy <blue%techunix.BITNET@qucdn.queensu.ca>
Ben Golding <bgg@pta.oz.au>
Bengt Larsson <bengtl@maths.lth.se>
Bill Bogstad <wjb@cogsci.cog.jhu.edu>
Bill Randle <billr%saab.cna.tek.com@RELAY.CS.NET>
Bob Narron <bob@ipac.caltech.edu>
Bruce Sherrod <bsherrod@rome.ICS.UCI.EDU>
Christopher Bryden <bryden@freezer.acs.udel.edu>
Christopher Mc Kulka <mckulka@endor.cs.psu.edu>
Clive Chinery <aisnet!clive@relay.EU.net>
Dan Poirier <poirier@cs.unc.edu>
Dave Allum <D.R.Allum@gdt.bath.ac.uk>
Dave Sill <de5@de5.ctd.ornl.gov>
David Herron <david@TWG.COM>
Doug Lee <dlee@athenanet.com>
Doug Sewell <DOUG@YSUB.YSU.EDU>
Douglas N. Arnold <dna@math.psu.edu>
Draphsor vo'drun-Aelf <draphsor@leland.Stanford.EDU>
Eamonn McManus <em@dce.ie>
Ed McGuire <emcguire@cadfx.ccad.uiowa.edu>
Ed Reed <mitel!uunet!leadsv!ereed>
Fergus O'Reilly <magic!fergus%crp.capsogeti.fr>
Geoff Kuenning <mitel!devnet.la.locus.com!geoff>
Gisle Hannemyr <gisle@ifi.uio.no>
Guy Middleton <gamiddleton@watmath.uwaterloo.ca>
James Beal <james_@cs.qmw.ac.uk>
James da Silva <jds@cs.UMD.EDU>
Jamie Blustein <jamie@gaul.csd.uwo.ca>
Jan van der Steen <jansteen@cwi.nl>
Jay Maynard <jmaynard@thesis1.hsch.utexas.edu>
Jean-Loup Gailly <jloup@chorus.fr>
Jeff Okamoto <okamoto@hpcc25.corp.hp.com>
Jeremy J Bolio <matrix@rpi.edu>
Jim Bevier - J B Systems <jbev@iscden.jbsys.com>
Jo Are Rosland <jar@ifi.uio.no>
John Coolidge <coolidge@cs.uiuc.edu>
John Romine <jromine@buckaroo.ICS.UCI.EDU>
Jussi Heinonen <thorens@utu.fi>
Larry Gillespie <tessi!larry@uunet.UU.NET>
Laszlo C. Balint <lba@kolvi.hut.fi>
Linh Ngo <L1NGO@CUDENVER>
Malcolm Mladenovic <mbm@dsbc.icl.stc.co.uk>
Marc Rouleau <mer6g@fuggles.acc.Virginia.EDU>
Mark Eichin <eichin@apollo.com>
Mark Nagel <nagel@buckaroo.ICS.UCI.EDU>
Mark Reinhold <mbr@larch.lcs.mit.edu>
Marty Ryba <marty@puppsr.Princeton.EDU>
Matthias Urlichs <urlichs%smurf.sub.org@RELAY.CS.NET>
Merri L Naka <mnaka@ICS.UCI.EDU>
Michel B. Cormier <micor!mcormier>
Palmer Davis <davisp@SCL.CWRU.Edu>
Patrick e. Fleming <pfleming@hpuxa.acs.ohio-state.edu>
ROEBER@CITHE1.CITHEP.CALTECH.EDU (Frederick G. M. Roeber)
Rein Tollevik <rein@ifi.uio.no>
Rick Ellis <rick@ofa123.fidonet.ORG>
Roger Fulton <roger@wrq.com>
Rupert G. Goldie <rgg@aaii.oz.au>
Sam Horrocks <sam@john-bigboote.ICS.UCI.EDU>
Scott Barman <mitel!nbc1.ge.com!scott>
Scott R. Weis KB2EAR <kb2ear!kb2ear@rutgers.edu>
Sean Philip Engelson <engelson-sean@CS.YALE.EDU>
Soren Larsen <larsen@imada.dk>
Stan Barber <sob@tmc.edu>
TWG!bill@wimsey.bc.ca@dgbt.doc.ca
Terry B Lyons <pride386!terry@uunet.uu.net>
Thomas Andreasson <and@sap-ag.de>
Tim Cook <timcc@admin.viccol.edu.au>
Tim Day <tday@ps.ucl.ac.uk>
Tim Morgan <morgan@john-parker.ICS.UCI.EDU>
Tom Anderson <toma@hpsadri.hp.com>
Tom Haapanen <tom@mims-iris.uwaterloo.ca>
Tom Roehl <stubby!tom@uunet.UU.NET>
Tony Wilson <shapetc!wilson@relay.EU.net>
Torben Lange <admitl@aau.dk>
ajt@mace.cc.purdue.edu (Andy Thomas)
akiko@pegasus.com (Akiko Katayama)
alan@msc.edu
ambar@artemis.ora.com (Jean Marie Diaz)
andy@icom.icom.com (Andrew H. Marrinson)
andyh@vuse.vanderbilt.edu (Bor-Jau Hsieh)
andyr@soc1.ssl.Berkeley.Edu (Andy Rose)
anthony@monu6.cc.monash.edu.au (Anthony Baxter)
arg@ccvr1.cc.ncsu.edu (Ron Gallant)
arnold@audiofax.com (Arnold Robbins)
ath@linkoping.telesoft.se
aurs01!aurw91!miles@mcnc.org (Robert Miles)
autodesk!melange!abeals@fernwood.mpk.ca.us (DOS: Tastes like chicken when properly prepared.)
bart@cs.uoregon.edu
bba@probe.att.com (Binayak Banerjee)
berson@cs.pitt.edu (David A. Berson)
biff@mentor.cc.purdue.edu
bill@twwells.com (T. William Wells)
bob@psitech.com (Bob Posert)
bobwhite@nova.ta52.lanl.gov (James R (Bob) White)
bwhite@inmet (Bill White)
cals@cals01.Newport.RI.US (Charles A. Sefranek)
celit!fpssun.fps.com!mbn.fps.com!mbn@UCSD.EDU (Mike Northam ext 2651)
cew@ISI.EDU (Craig E. Ward)
chris@rsl-egg.com (Chris Greve)
christos@guillemin.EE.CORNELL.EDU (Christos S. Zoulas)
cognos!cunews!alzabo.ocunix.on.ca!kebera (Krishna E. Bera)
coleman@twinsun.com (Mike Coleman)
curt@cynic.wimsey.bc.ca (Curt J. Sampson)
danj1@ihlpz.att.com (Daniel Jacobson)
dave@Galaxia.Newport.RI.US (David H. Brierley)
david@glacier.ICS.UCI.EDU
davide%cadillac.cad.mcc.com@mcc.com (David Eckelkamp)
dciem!bkj386!brian (Brian Jenkins)
dciem!chrisj%netcom.com (Christopher Jewell)
dciem!corondan%eds.com
dciem!doug%letni.LoneStar.org (Doug Davis)
dciem!gatech!scicom.alphacdc.com!rcw (Robert White)
dciem!gatech!uncecs.edu!thebeach.UUCP!meto (nobody)
dciem!jmm%eci386 (John Macdonald)
dciem!nelson%berlioz.nsc.com (Taed Nelson)
dciem!nick%ryelect (Nick Colonello)
dciem!rancor!bob%cs.utexas.edu (Bob Willcox)
dciem!rducky!jrp%polyslo.calpoly.edu (JIM PICKERING)
dciem!seachg!jalsop (John Alsop)
dciem!smu!letni!ataritx!dwh%cs.utexas.edu (Dave Hanna)
dciem!steve%txsil.lonestar.org (Steve McConnel)
dcm@pyrite.nj.pyramid.com (David C. Miller)
delaney@mentor.cc.purdue.edu (Eric Delaney)
dfreuden@govt.shearson.com (David G Freudenstein)
dglo@ads.com (Dave Glowacki)
doctor@von-neumann.info.polymtl.ca (Paul Do (News))
dprmjc@Arco.COM (M. J. Cole)
dsndata!wayne@uunet.UU.NET (Wayne Schlitt)
dupuy@hudson.cs.columbia.edu (Alexander Dupuy)
edhew@xenitec.on.ca (Ed Hew)
electro!carlo@watcgl.uwaterloo.ca (Carlo Sgro)
fitz@wang.com (Tom Fitzgerald)
fred@cc.uit.no
fritzz@lamont.ldgo.columbia.edu (fritz zaucker)
frk@sybase.com (frank korzeniewski)
frnkmth!frnk400!jesse@decwrl.dec.com (Jesse Perry)
gatech!uflorida!rm1!bapat (Subodh Bapat)
genek@mentor.cc.purdue.edu (Gene Kim)
geoff@sigmawa.UUCP@munnari.oz.au
geyer@galton.uchicago.edu
goehring@gnu.ai.mit.edu
gs26@prism.gatech.edu (Glenn R. Stone)
gtoal@tardis.computer-science.edinburgh.ac.uk
gvr@cs.brown.edu (George V. Reilly)
hassey@dg-rtp.dg.com (John Hassey)
hpubvwa!ssc!Mark.Zenier@cs.washington.edu
hrubin@pop.stat.purdue.edu (Herman Rubin)
iczer-1!emm@uunet.uu.net
inesc!fmhv@relay.EU.net (Fernando Manuel Vasconcelos)
inesc!rpc@relay.EU.net (Rui Casteleiro)
isgtec!ted (Ted Richards)
jba@gorm.ruc.dk (Jan B.Andersen)
jbd@dasteel.dasteel (Jonathan Dasteel)
jcc@axis-design.fr (Jean-Christophe Collet)
jcm@squid.adi.com (John Martin)
jef@ee.lbl.gov (Jef Poskanzer)
jesup@cbmvax.cbm.commodore.com (Randell Jesup)
jfw@ksr.com (John F. Woods)
jgabriel@mtecv2.mty.itesm.mx (Juan Gabriel Ruiz Pinto)
jhf@cblpe.att.com (Jeffri H Frontz)
jimr@maths.su.oz.au (Jim Richardson)
jnemeth@cue (John Nemeth)
jpn@genrad.com (John P. Nelson)
keenan@inmet.inmet.com (Keenan Ross )
kirk@ico.isc.com (Kirk Webb)
kmcvay@oneb.wimsey.bc.ca (Ken McVay)
kolb@kub.nl (Hans-Peter Kolb)
ksb@nostromo.cc.purdue.edu (Kevin Braunsdorf)
lerman@stepstone.com (Ken Lerman)
levisonm@qucis.queensu.ca (Mark Levison)
lingnau@rbiffm.rbi.informatik.uni-frankfurt.de (Anselm Lingnau)
lmb@sat.com (Larry Blair)
lwj@cs.kun.nl
lwv27%CAS.BITNET@QUCDN.QueensU.CA
malloy@nprdc.navy.mil (Sean Malloy)
marlor@dream.sublink.org (Marco Lorenzini)
martelli@hp400p.sublink.org (Alex Martelli)
maslen@Eng.Sun.COM (Thomas Maslen)
meissner@osf.org
mellon@nigiri.pa.dec.com (Ted Lemon)
metcalf@mamane.IFA.Hawaii.Edu (Tom Metcalf)
milhow1!how@uunet.uu.net
miron@cs.sfu.ca@dgbt.doc.ca
mitel!ddsw1.mcs.com!kestrel (Ryan Pazdur)
mitel!happym.wa.com!irving (Irving_Wolfe on reddog)
mitel!indetech.com!david (David Kuder x2003)
mitel!juts.ccc.amdahl.com!ked01 (Kim DeVaughn)
mitel!mport.com!lee (Lee Crocker)
mitel!onion.rain.com!jeff (Jeff Beadles)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!kent (Kent Landfield)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!rick (Richard Ohnemus)
mitel!uunet!ars2!briank
mitel!uunet!coplex!dean (Dean Brooks)
mitel!uunet!infmx!crickhollow!cortesi (David Cortesi)
mjd@saul.cis.upenn.edu (Mark-Jason Dominus)
moon!jh@uunet.UU.NET (John Harkin)
muir@CSI.COM (David Muir Sharnoff)
neil@wcc.oz.au (Neil Murray)
nixbur!koerber.sin@uunet.uu.net
nv90-mho@nada.kth.se
nyssa!lingua7!steve@unicorn.cc.wwu.edu (Steven C. Work)
ooms@delgeo.nl (Frank Ooms)
paj <paj@gec-mrc.co.uk>
pda@Dixie.Com (Paul D. Anderson)
peter@taronga.hackercorp.com (Peter da Silva)
philip@itd.dsto.oz.au (Philip Dart)
pjg@acsu.buffalo.edu (Paul Graham)
rfinch@locke.water.ca.gov (Ralph Finch)
richard@pegasus.com (Richard Foulk)
rjh@btc.kodak.com (Rod Holland)
ro@thp.Uni-Koeln.DE
rob%phavl@uunet.UU.NET (Robert Ransbottom)
rob@epoch.com (Rob Kenna)
roger@xn.ll.mit.edu
root@cca.ucsf.EDU (Systems Staff)
rorschak@daimi.aau.dk
rothstei@mcs.kent.edu (Michael Rothstein)
russell@ccu1.aukuni.ac.nz
ryan@aladdin.b11.ingr.com (Ryan Waldron)
sandia!marms@unmvax.cs.unm.edu (Mike Arms)
scs@lokkur.dexter.mi.us (Steve Simmons)
shaver@orion.convex.com (Dave Shaver)
skrenta@amix.commodore.com (Rich Skrenta)
slamont@network.UCSD.EDU (Steve Lamont)
sliu@el-shaddai.sbi.com (Steven C. Liu)
smith!dick@nrtc.northrop.com
spencer@spline.eecs.umich.edu
stb@isbank.is (Steintor Bjarnason)
steen@kiku.dk (Steen Hammerum)
steve@nuchat.sccsi.com (Steve Nuchia)
stripes@eng.umd.edu (Joshua Osborne)
syd@dsinc.dsi.com (Syd Weinstein)
tar@math.ksu.edu (Tim Ramsey)
taube@isa.de (Christian Taube)
tct!chip@uunet.UU.NET (Chip Salzenberg)
tdinger@East.Sun.COM (Tom Dinger - Sun BOS SPA)
tibor%autro1.UUCP@nac.no (Tibor Stern jr.)
tim@grenada.bellcore.com (Tim J Ihde)
tima@CFSMO.Honeywell.COM (Timothy D Aanerud)
tom@hcx2.SSD.CSD.HARRIS.COM (Tom Horsley)
tombre@loria.crin.fr (Karl Tombre)
tvf@sun01.cci.com (Tom Frauenhofer)
vp@fct.unl.pt
vp@fct.unl.pt (Vasco Pedro)
wex@PWS.BULL.COM
wht@n4hgf.Mt-Park.GA.US (Warren Tucker)
wilber@alice.att.com
win@incom.de (Winfried Koenig)
wolves.uucp!delong@mcnc.org
wolves.uucp!ggw@mcnc.org (Gregory G. Woodbury)
wolves.uucp!hebert@mcnc.org (Jim Hebert)
wolves.uucp!jim@mcnc.org
"No" votes:
"Douglas F. DeJulio" <dd26+@andrew.cmu.edu>
"Neil Rickert, N Illinois U, CS" <rickert@cs.niu.edu>
"The Wandering Wizard" <uunet!vampire!network_mgr>
6sceng!blm@cs.washington.edu (Brian Matthews)
Brett K. Carver <brett@hpsrbkc.hp.com>
Dan Schlitt <dan@sci.ccny.cuny.edu>
Eric Olson <ejo@ims.alaska.edu>
Jean-Francois Rit <rit@killdeer.Stanford.EDU>
Joel B Levin <levin@BBN.COM>
John Curran <jcurran@SH.CS.NET>
John Lacey <basho!john@cis.ohio-state.edu>
Magnus Olsson <magnus@thep.lu.se>
Matthew Farwell <dylan@ibmpcug.co.uk>
Ozan Yigit <oz@nexus.yorku.ca>
Ralph Clark <clark@ttidcb.tti.com>
Richard H. Miller <rick@crick.ssctr.bcm.tmc.edu>
Shannon D. Appel <appel@ocf.Berkeley.EDU>
Steve Hayman <sahayman@iuvax.cs.indiana.edu>
Timothy VanFosson <timv@cadfx.ccad.uiowa.edu>
Tom Christiansen <tchrist@pixel.convex.com>
Tom Epperly <epperly@osnome.che.wisc.edu>
ado@elsie.nci.nih.gov (Arthur David Olson)
brnstnd@KRAMDEN.ACF.NYU.EDU (Dan Bernstein)
ctuel@polyslo.CalPoly.EDU (Cliff Tuel)
david@elroy.Jpl.Nasa.Gov (David Robinson)
davidsen@crdos1.crd.ge.com
dciem!6sceng!blm%cs.washington.edu (Brian Matthews)
dciem!letni!digi.lonestar.org!kgallagh%utacfd.uta.edu (Kevin Gallagher)
dciem!woods%eci386 (Greg A. Woods)
eps@toaster.SFSU.EDU (Eric P. Scott)
gary@proa.sv.dg.com (Gary Bridgewater)
jcs@uafhp.uark.edu (James Sullins)
jgd@Dixie.Com (John G. DeArmond)
jlitvin@st860.intel.com (John Litvin)
karl@ficc.ferranti.com (karl lehenbauer)
lear@turbo.bio.net (Eliot)
lsuc!linus!russ%shannon.Alliant.COM (Russell McFatter)
merlyn@iWarp.intel.com (Randal L. Schwartz)
mikel@mozart.AMD.COM (Michael W. Wellman)
mitel!psg.com!news (Randy Bush)
mitel!pyramid.pyramid.com!csg (Carl S. Gutekunst)
mitel!se-sd.SanDiego.NCR.COM!bhoule (Bill Houle)
mitel!uunet!vicstoy!jellis (Jacob Ellis)
nazgul@alfalfa.com (Kee Hinckley)
oc@VMP.COM (Orlan Cannon)
osyjm@caesar.cs.montana.edu (Jaye Mathisen)
paul@devon.lns.pa.us (Paul Sutcliffe Jr.)
pda@Dixie.Com (Paul D. Anderson)
peirce@gumby.cc.wmich.edu (Leonard Peirce)
poulin@acsu.buffalo.edu (Marc C. Poulin)
raymond@math.berkeley.edu (Raymond Chen)
rsk@juniper.circ.upenn.edu (Rich Kulawiec)
schaller@hsi86.hsi.com (Dave V. Schaller)
vandys@sequent.com
One person voted both "yes" and "no":
Date: 28 Feb 91 10:14:02 EST (Thu)
From: pda@Dixie.Com (Paul D. Anderson)
"I vote YES for comp.sources.reviewed."
---
* Paul Anderson * Dixie Communications * (404) 578-9547 * pda@dixie.com *
Date: 4 Mar 91 10:42:52 EST (Mon)
From: pda@Dixie.Com (Paul D. Anderson)
Status: OR
"I vote NO for comp.sources.reviewed."
---
* Paul Anderson * Dixie Communications * (404) 578-9547 * pda@dixie.com *
These two votes were ignored.
--
Andrew Patrick, Ph.D. Department of Communications, Ottawa, CANADA
andrew@calvin.doc.CA
"The interface IS the program."