[comp.protocols.iso.dev-environ] FTAM node-names

karen@informatics.rutherford.ac.uk (02/25/91)

In ISODE 6.0 FTAM, the FADUidentity structure allows a FADU to 
be specified by name or list-of-names. In each case, simple 
null-terminated strings are assumed.

As far as I know (and I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm
wrong on this!), there is nothing in the FTAM standard which
restricts node-names in the VFS to such easily handled objects.
One could imagine a document type where the logical choice for
a name was a particular chunk of (binary) data from the file,
embedded nulls and all.

This in fact almost happened recently for the emerging FTAM-6 
document type (for handling of Computer Graphics Metafiles).
When it was decided to stick to printable strings, I heaved a
big sigh of relief, as I am involved in adding support for FTAM-6 
to ISODE as part of the ESPRIT II project "ARGOSI".

Now I am wondering, although I don't need it immediately,  whether 
it would not be for the long-term best if ISODE's FADUidentity 
structure specified names as bounded strings (a "char*" and 
an "int" giving the string length) rather than just "char *".  
Up till now ISODE has not made much use of FADU names, so if 
such a change ought to be made this would be an excellent time 
to do it. What do you people think?

Karen

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Karen Goswell                                  DCSD, Informatics Department
Usenet:{... | mcvax}!ukc!rlinf!karen         Rutherford Appleton Laboratory
JANET: karen@uk.ac.rl.inf                             Chilton, Didcot, Oxon
ARPA:  karen%inf.rl.ac.uk@nfsnet-relay.ac.uk                   OX11 0QX, UK