[soc.religion.christian] Why I No Longer Believe the Doctrine Sola Scriptura

lieuwen@mycella.cs.wisc.edu (Dan Lieuwen) (08/06/90)

I believe that the Bible is the primary source of truth and that all that is
contrary to Scripture must be rejected.  However, I reject the doctrine
that the Bible is 
sufficient as an interpreter of itself.  The belief that the Bible is
self-interpreting leads to terrible errors--and hands control of the church to 
the rootless and the ruthless.  By rootless, I mean those like the
Jehovah's Witnesses who fall into grave error because they ignore the
clear teaching of the church through the ages and return to ancient heresies.
By ruthless, I mean those who shove their agendas through church decision
making bodies--agendas that conflict with scripture, tradition, and even the
will of the layity.  A good example is the recent decision of the
Christian Reformed Church to ordain women ministers using a hermeneutic
that has been used to argue for the ordination of homosexuals.

The doctrice Sola Scriptura has a noble aim:  to proclaim the wonder
of God's Word and to refuse to allow the teachings of men to crowd it out.
It was, however, based on a misunderstanding.  Tradition's function is not
to cancel out Scripture but to explain it and to supplement it.  It gives
us the eye glasses through which we may see Scripture correctly.
It keeps us from errors old and new.  It allows to wonder of God's Word
to shine forth with full vigor, unclouded by error.

Dan Lieuwen, a current member of the Christian Reformed Church headed who
		knows where
--
	
	--Dan