[soc.religion.christian] A Meta-question

st0o+@andrew.cmu.edu (Steven Timm) (12/06/90)

Frank Farkas has pointed out some verses from James which suggest that 
good works are important in the life of a Christian.

He was responding to a post which re-iterated that faith is the only 
determining factor in salvation.

I agree with both of the above points.

Sure, faith in Christ is what will save you.  But is your own salvation the
ultimate goal of your practice of religion.  Do you have faith in  Christ
only because of the benefits that faith will bring to you?  If so, doesn't
that make your religion a religion of self-centeredness, focusing on 
what *you* do to save *your* soul.

Ditto for the rationale for good works.  If you do good works to get a 
temple recommend, or to get into the "third heavens"  (celestial kingdom
in mormonspeak) or because you believe you will be judged by them,
then you are trying to save your own hide and are missing the whole reason
for doing good works.

The reason for good works (even faith in Christ, even baptism--everything
that we do in our Christian life) is to share the love of God with others,
and return it to Him.  Good works result, not from fear or desire for 
personal gain, but from the overflowing love of God as manifested in our lives.

Steve Timm

Steven Timm  Physics Department  Carnegie Mellon
"Shame on you, and shame on you again
    for converting me into a bullet and
         shooting me into men's hearts."    Richard Harris  c 1972

farkas@eng.sun.com (Frank Farkas) (12/11/90)

In article <Dec.6.03.50.55.1990.23658@athos.rutgers.edu>, st0o+@andrew.cmu.edu (Steven Timm) writes:
>Frank Farkas has pointed out some verses from James which suggest that 
>good works are important in the life of a Christian.
>
Deleted some of the text.

>The reason for good works (even faith in Christ, even baptism--everything
>that we do in our Christian life) is to share the love of God with others,
>and return it to Him.  Good works result, not from fear or desire for 
>personal gain, but from the overflowing love of God as manifested in our lives.
>

Thanks Steve, for summarizing the issues in your very well worded comments.
I agree with you 100%. Anyone who believes, baptised, goes to the LDS temple,
helps others, etc., without having the above described attitude and state
of mind, without being filled with gratitude and thanksgiving, and doesn't
glorifying God, misses the whole point.

>Steve Timm

Thanks again. With brotherly love,

			Frank

gross@dg-rtp.dg.com (Gene Gross) (12/24/90)

In article <Dec.6.03.50.55.1990.23658@athos.rutgers.edu> st0o+@andrew.cmu.edu (Steven Timm) writes:
>Frank Farkas has pointed out some verses from James which suggest that 
>good works are important in the life of a Christian.
>
>He was responding to a post which re-iterated that faith is the only 
>determining factor in salvation.
>
>I agree with both of the above points.
>
>Sure, faith in Christ is what will save you.  But is your own salvation the
>ultimate goal of your practice of religion.  Do you have faith in  Christ
>only because of the benefits that faith will bring to you?  If so, doesn't
>that make your religion a religion of self-centeredness, focusing on 
>what *you* do to save *your* soul.

Steve, I think we need to make a distinction here.  No one starts off
with such altruistic motives.  Like babies (the Biblical analogy is so
apt), we start off very self-focused.  As we grow in Christ, we begin to
move out from ourselves into the world about us to share that which we
have found in Christ.  And even at this, we tend to do good works at
first because it gives us pleasure to do so, and less because we are
doing right simply because it is right.

The distinction that I would draw is between immature and mature faith.
Immature faith centers, like a baby, on itself and the benefits that
come from believing.  Mature faith is one that reaches out beyond itself
to a world in desparate need, seeking no personal gain or need, and
ministers to that need.  No Christian that I have ever known has started
off with mature faith.

Other than this nit, I liked what you said.

Yours in Christ,

Gene Gross