[net.auto] seat belts vs air bags

henry (08/17/82)

I will take belts any day over air bags.  The most basic reason is that
they are so much simpler that they have got to be more reliable, and
safety devices absolutely must be as reliable as possible.  Getting
trapped is a legitimate worry, but that can happen whether you are
wearing a belt or not.  An important side effect of belts, which should
not be taken lightly, is that a driver who is firmly strapped in is
considerably more likely to retain control in an accident.  It is not
an accident that airline pilots have elaborate lap-and-shoulder belts.

Given a choice, in fact, I would take a form of belt that you can't get
any more:  plain adjustable belts with fixed mounts.  For reliability
in an accident and firm restraint during violent maneuvering,  these
have got to score higher than inertia-reel mechanisms.  (Again, note
what airliners are equipped with.)  Sure, they are a bit more work to
put on, but if you follow safety rules only when they are convenient
you are not long for this world anyway.

					Henry Spencer
					U of Toronto