[net.auto] Radial Snow Tires -- Worth It?

prgclb (10/27/82)

I'd like to get a sampling of opinions on whether radial
snow tires are worth getting.  I've heard two sides to the
story -- the "experts" (i.e. tire companies, who naturally
want to sell tires) say that regular radials are really not
meant to be used as a snow tire, but most radial tire users
feel their regular tires do just fine.

Here's my situation -- my wife is driving her 1980 Chevy Malibu
back and forth to school (60 miles round-trip), mostly over
two-lane country road.  We live in northern Illinois, where
snow can get deep!  Around town, they salt liberally, so she
didn't find snow tires necessary.  But she'd like a somewhat
reliable means of traction out in the country.

Incidentally, I've used plastic chains, which work wonderfully
in deep snow.  They're a whole lot easier to put on than metal
chains, and easier to drive with, yet it does take some doing
to attach them, and it's best done in a warm garage!  Therefore,
I don't consider the plastic chains to be a viable alternative
for my wife on her winter commute to school.

I'll appreciate any and all opinions!

Thanks,
Carl Blesch
IH 2A-159, x3360
ihuxj!prgclb

larry (10/27/82)

As far as I'm concerned there is NO  "normal" tire that is sufficient
for Chicago winters.  It is after all the rib design that determines how
well you will get thru unplowed streets  *not* the orientation of the
cords that hold the tire together.  Granted radials tend to keep more of
the rubber on the road than non-radials.  I also grant you that normal
tires have more traction on glare ice than snow tires (more rubber on
the ice), but I think the time spent on glare ice is rather small.

By the way I would assume the question whether to have snow tires or not
--not the actual design of the tires.  Only a very foolish person would
MIX the type of tires they had on  the car in the winter time!!



		Larry Marek
		 ihuxf!larry
		  IX 1B-423 0859