[net.auto] a simple solution to the drunk driving problem

ark (12/14/82)

Every time I think about what measures are appropriate for the government
to deal with drunk driving, I come up with problems.  For instance,
what is "drunk"?  While several states have specific limits for
blood alcohol, I refuse to believe that someone with X percent blood
alcohol will display an "amount of drunkenness" that is independent of
the individual involved.  To put it differently, whatever threshold you
choose, there will be some people who are incapable of controlling a car
with much less alcohol than that, and others who are perfectly competent
with considerably more.

Unless you believe that people should be prohibited from driving after
ingesting any alcohol at all, you have to admit that this approach causes
problems.

I have another suggestion.  Let the free market take care of it, as follows:
A driver is responsible for any damage caused by his actions behind the
wheel.  Being drunk, stoned, or insane is no defense.  Now, let (encourage,
but do not require) insurance companies base their rates, in part, on
the driver's past history of being involved in alcohol-related accidents.
I'll bet that the insurance companies will be a lot tougher than any
state governments, especially as they are not bound by all this "due process"
stuff.  If you can't find anyone to take on your risks (insure you), and
you aren't willing to post a financial security bond, you can't drive.
If you drive without evidence of financial responsibility (insurance card
or posting bond), that should be a felony, like fraud.

wagner (12/15/82)

The simple solution to the drinking problem put forward here
(if you can't get insurance or post a bond, you have a history
of drinking and therefore shouldnt drive) is unworkable, because
it gives licence(sp?) to the wealthy to drive when drunk.

Michael Wagner, UTCS

hsc (12/15/82)

One bright spot is that a large chunk of moped sales are to people with
auto licenses suspended for drunk driving.  I think that depriving
drunk drivers of 90% of their armor and 90% of theirhorsepower is wonderful.  Now if we could just forbid them from wearing helmets
...
Harvey S. Cohen 1C314 American Bell, Lincroft, NJ 07748 (201)576-6059 hogpc!hsc