[comp.ai.shells] SHELL COMPARISON

carasso@aludra.usc.edu (Roger RDC Carasso) (02/13/91)

This info was given to me by a friend who is a knowledge engineer:

Expert Systems Tool Comparison
------------------------------
			Art-IM        Nexpert      KBMS
			by Inference  Neuron Data  AICORP
------------------------------------------------------------------
Written in 		C		C		C

Platforms	
  PC			Y		Y		Y
  Mini			Y		Y		N
  Mainframe		Y		N		Y
  Workstation		Y		Y		N

Operating Systems
And Packages
  UNIX			Y		Y		N
  DOS			Y		Y		Y
  WINDOWS		Y		Y		N
  MVS			Y		N		N
  VMS			Y		Y		N
  OS2			Y		Y		Y

Reasoning Strategies 
  Forward Chaining      Y		Y		Y
  Backward Chaining     (Y)		Y		Y
  Mixed 		(Y)		Y		Y
  Uncertainty Reasoning (Y)		(Y)		N
  Hypothetical Reasoning (Y)		(Y)		(Y)
  Object Oriented	Y		Y		Y
  Truth Maintenance	Y		N		N

Knowledge Representation
  Multiple Inheritance    	Y	N		Y
  Override of Inheritance 	Y	Y		Y
  Full inheritance of defaults  Y	N		Y
  Structured values		Y	N		N
  Methods			Y	Y		Y

Professional Services
  Tutorial		Y		N		Y
  Product Training  	Y		N		Y
  Consulting		Y		N		N

Y = YES
N = NO
(Y) = No, but can be easily built in native language

---------------------
Roger

ntm1169@dsac.dla.mil (Mott Given) (02/19/91)

From article <7539@uklirb.informatik.uni-kl.de>, by carasso@aludra.usc.edu (Roger RDC Carasso):
   
     The article comparing the shells erroneously states that Nexpert is
     not available for mainframes.  It is available for mainframes and will
     run under MVS.

-- 
Mott Given @ Defense Logistics Agency Systems Automation Center,
             DSAC-TMP, Bldg. 27-1, P.O. Box 1605, Columbus, OH 43216-5002
INTERNET:  mgiven@dsac.dla.mil   UUCP: ...{osu-cis}!dsac!mgiven
Phone:  614-238-9431  AUTOVON: 850-9431   FAX: 614-238-9928 I speak for myself