[net.auto] High Insurance Cost

perry@nmtvax.UUCP (09/21/84)

       
       
       
       Just examining things, I was wondering if a large number of  peo-
       ple where paying  auto insurance that was close to what they paid
       for their car.  This came to mind because of what I have  to  pay
       for insurance.

       My Story:

       A couple of months ago I bought a 1976 TR7.  The only stain in an
       otherwise  perfect  driving  record is an accident two and a half
       years ago (I fell asleep behind the wheel), just after I  got  my
       license.   I  am  a nineteen-year-old, unmarried, college student
       (with good grades).  I got the minimum insurance required by  the
       state  of  New  Mexico.  The car cost $1000 (it needs a paint job
       and  interior).   The  insurance,  minus  finance  charges,  cost
       $700/year.

       I personally believe that this ratio is a little high.   What  do
       you think?  Let's see what kind of discussion we can get going.

       Allan F. Perry
       ...lanl-a!nmtvax!perry
       ...lanl-a!nmtvax!robin

m2002cl@othervax.UUCP (09/27/84)

<..>

Most of that $700 that you are paying for insurance is for
third party damage should you have an accident and cause 
some poor Joe to wrap his car and himself around a tree.

I strongly suspect that for a car of $1000 value they
(the insurance people) are not too worried about what
you might do to it yourself. 

I would think that if you did any major damage to your car
they would just scrap it (with compensation of course) instead
of trying to fix it. However, if you were involved in an accident
(and you were to blame) and you wrote off some other guy's $15,000
car, the insurance company would be footing the bill.

It doesn't really surprise me that your insurance is so high,
considering that you are young (under 25!), are driving a sports
car, and have already had one accident. 
I don't think that $700 is overly expensive when all the above is
considered, and I have seen rates *much* higher than that for people
older, wiser etc.

cheers,    Scott Pace

marcus@pyuxt.UUCP (M. G. Hand) (09/29/84)

So, you fell asleep at the wheel and wonder why an unmarried college
student of 19 has to pay $700 dollars for insurance?  Well the answer
is that you are a high risk.  The insurance is geared towards what
damage you might cause in your TR6 (a high speed projectile with the
cornering characteristics of a brick), not towards the value of your
particular car.

You should not move to New Jersey too soon,  you might have an
apoplectic fit if you asked for a quotation.

Incidentally, my RX7 costs me a few dollars over $1000 per year,
and I have been driving for 10 years without accident (they still weight
me as a youthfull male because I'm not married).   The last
insurance quote I got in England for a Triumph Spitfire, 4years
old was #148 (say, $180 at todays exchange rates) - the 60% no-
claims-discount helped alot.

		Marcus Hand (pyuxt!marcus)