erv@everest.TANDEM.COM (E. Videki) (03/23/91)
Archive-name: languages/oberon/oberon-m/1991-03-22 Archive: ucsd.edu:/pub/oberonm.* [128.54.16.1] Original-posting-by: erv@everest.TANDEM.COM (E. Videki) Original-subject: Oberon-M Q's and A's Reposted-by: emv@msen.com (Edward Vielmetti, MSEN) This is about the Oberon-M(tm) package for the MSDOS environment. Here are answers to questions that I've been repeatedly asked: Q: Does this use real Intel/MSDOS-like object files? A: Yes, in fact in a form that I expect is even compatible with all older releases. This causes some non-Intel-based linkers (such as one from Borland) to give occasional warning messages, but everything works fine even under those cases. Q: What kind of garbage collector do you use? A: The MSDOS environment (particularly older releases) don't work well with programs taking over full storage management -- especially when many and varied terminate and stay resident programs are present. As with Oberon itself, simplicity is refreshing, so although I once had a garbage collector its use was questionable under DOS, and it is not present in this package. You can, of course, do NEW(objectptrs) on anything that will fit, but there is no automatic retrieval of storage (until your program ends). Of course you could always write your own storage manager (it can be very powerful while still being very simple). Q: What about the Oberon System? A: As explaned in different words in my earlier posting, the Oberon system is an extensible operating environment with user interfaces and automatic storage management. MSDOS likes to own these things all by itself mostly. My compiler and package is best thought of as a way to write programs using the advanced and elegant features of Oberon in the popular MSDOS world. Q: What's the product's official name? A: It is called Oberon-M(tm), and I hold the trademark rights as well as copyrights to it. Further, it is my sole intellectual property. It is being released in the form of license-to-use. Q: What about other legal requirements, etc ? A: The package itself specifies these, but a summary of the details are: 1) I retain full copyright of this package, especially the compiler and the implementation approach. 2) Use of the package is by license, at the moment with fee waved. The user does not own the package, only has rights to use it. 3) The user may not redistribute the package or the compiler or the associated tools to other users, in any way. This means I don't want it given out by third parties, and of course never sold by them, nor represented as being their property. Network distribution is an exception to the prohibition of multi-level distribution. 4) Users may write programs, use the distributed library modules with their programs, and even modify for their own use the library modules (but not the compiler). Such user programs may be distributed without fee or royalties to me. 5) My copyright notices may never be removed from the package contents itself. 6) No warrantees or guarantees are expressed or implied. Use of the package in any and all ways is entirely the user's responsibility and risk. Q: How long will use of this be "no charge", ie: the license fee is waved? A: On this release, no specific period has been decided upon. Q: What are the specific, technical things the compiler does not do? A: Here are the things that the compiler does NOT do now, or could be viewed by some as being deviations from the Oberon language report by Niklaus Wirth: 1) No floating point support in this release. 2) 8088 and 8086 (ie: the oldest processors) do not have Enter and Leave instructions which are generated by the compiler. Thus, only PCs with 80x86 (where x >= 1) processors can use the produced code. The compiler itself will run on an older machine, though. 3) The produced code has not been tested under all versions of MSDOS that exist in the world, but I anticipate no problems. Some of the library modules may have differences in internal calls for very-odd MSDOS flavors; source for these are supplied so you may make modifications if you are running one of these rare DOS systems. 4) The ETH Zurich Oberon System permits "code procedures" identified by a minus sign in the procedure header. This is non-standard, very machine dependent, and not allowed on my compiler. However, module SYSTEM exports a predefined CODE procedure which takes bytes to insert in the instruction stream. 5) You MUST use the compiler hint "*" on a procedure definition if that procedure is going to be assigned to a procedural-typed variable (so that 80x86 long-calls will be generated). This looks like this, and is part of the Oberon language: PROCEDURE * MyHandler(.... Trying to assign a procedure without the "*" indicator results in a type incompatibility error at compile time. Note that this is different than the export mark "*" which follows the procedure name. 6) Due to the irregularities of the 80x86 architecture, code generation for it is ponderous. In my experience most professional programmers don't need or want the overhead of range or stack checking, so that is not provided. Of course, this is a debatable issue. 7) To make very sure programs using system dependent features (ie: the built-in machine specific system support module) are identified by the compiler, our system support module is called "SYS" (whereas the one from ETH is named "SYSTEM"). Excepting the exported CODE procedure, it functions the same as defined as SYSTEM in Niklaus Wirth's report. I am considering changing this name to SYSTEM in the next release, and if you have a strong opinion, please tell me about it. Q: Can't I please get this package in some way other than FTP or uudecode of mail messages ? A: Sorry, the demand is too great to respond to special requests for free. Q: What's the size of the whole package? A: In compressed (ZIP) format, it is about 151K, expanding to about 250K or so, including the PostScript(tm) documentation. In uuencode format (in mail messages) it is about 210K. The compiler itself is merely 78K. Q: What's in the package, specifically? A: Compiler, library modules in source/symbolic/object forms, sample programs, an extensive README file instructing how to use the package, a report on the Oberon language, and an EBNF summary of the syntax (these must be downloaded to a PostScript-handling printer or printer driver). Q: "I sent you a logon/password/subdirectory to put the files on my machine. What are you going to do with that information now that you are distributing this package through anonymous FTP and uudecode mail?" A: Nothing. It is destroyed as confidential information. I come from the old school of hacking that respects privacy as a rule of existence. -- E. R. Videki 18 March 91 erv @ k2.tandem.everest.com (130.252.59.153) ....