[net.auto] Super unleaded vs. Regular unleaded gasoline

ksp@ulysses.UUCP (Krishna Prasad) (07/24/85)

Thanks to everyone who replied to my questions 
about which gas I should use for my new Dodge
Daytona.  

The general opinion was that I should use the lowest 
octane gas on which my car runs without knocking.  
A couple of responses gave detailed explanations of what     
compression was and and what knocking meant.  I also did
some research on my own.  My conclusions were as follows:

In general, knocking is more likely to occur in high 
compression, high performance engines.  I looked up a 
book giving engine specifications and found that the 
engines which you would normally think of as high 
performance as indeed high performance.  Examples are
Audi, BMW, Saab, and the VW Golf GLI.  Almost all Ford 
and GM cars tend to be very low compression and have very
low HP/engine volume ratios.  Chrysler and Japanese cars
generaly fall in between.  I derived a thumb rule that cars 
with compression ratios of above 9.25 were definitely high
performance and needed premium unleaded.  Cars with ratios
of under 9.0 would definitely be satisfied with regular 87 
octane gas.  In between use your judgement.  

This thumb rule is of course, a simplification.  I remember
from a undergraduate Internal Combustion engines class that
such factors as the material used to make the cylinders, and the 
shape of the cavity can affect the proclivity to knock.  

My engine has a compression ratio of 9.0 
and I haven't heard it knock yet.  However, after all
the careful and scientific analysis, and considering other
factors not related to engine dynamics, such as the fact that
this is my first car,  I am not married and I don't currently 
have a girlfriend to lavish attention on, and I make    
reasonable money,  I decided, "Oh, what the hell, I am 
going to use Premium Unleaded".  So much for science.  

Thanks to all those who replied.  

Krishna.