[gnu.emacs.bug] bug? starting up emacs from .rootmenu

mattie@SUN1.CHEM.UPENN.EDU (Renee Mattie) (06/02/89)

First of all, I am using
GNU Emacs 18.54.1 
on a sun 3/50.
The version I am using was built on our server
Everything is running under Sun OS 4.0-1

Here's what happens:
I have the following line in my .rootmenu:
"Gnu2"                    shelltool -B invert -I exec\ /home/local/bin/emacs                               -Wp 0 74 -Ws 732 657 -WP 1088 84                                               -WI /home/emacs/dist-18.54/etc/emacs.icon

That's all one line -- .rootmenu wouldn't have it any other way.
the space after 'exec' is escaped because the man pages recommended
I do it that way.

When I select this entry from the .rootmenu, Here's what happens:
1) the shelltool opens up with namestripe 
"shelltool - /home/local/bin/emacs"
and at the top of the blank screen the string
"exec\"
The cursor is at the beginning of the next line

2) at approximately the same time:
   a) the cursor moves to be right after the \
   b) the status line appears, identifying the buffer as *scratch*
   c) I get a beep, and in the message window
     "Symbol's value as variable is void: exec\377"
   d) The "startup message" -- GNU EMacs 18.54.1 of ... Type C-h t for a tutorial on using Emacs.

Here's what happened when I copied that command out of the .rootmenu 
and executed it from a shelltool:

1)  The shelltool window opened as above, but with the name stripe
shelltool - /bin/csh  and the line
"exec /home/local/bin/emacs"
in the window. The cursor was on the line following

2)  My shell prompt sun1% appeared.

3)  Emacs appeared to start up normally, with its "startup message"
    and everything.

There is nothing in my .emacs file but
(put 'narrow-to-region 'disabled nil)
There is no defaults.el file for our system.
The term/*.el files have not been modified.

Is this a bug, or some confusing (to me) interaction between what 
suntools does with .rootmenu commands and  what emacs does with
the command line?

Renee Peloquin Mattie
mattie@sun1.chem.upenn.edu
mattie@a.chem.upenn.edu
(215)898-8424
Department of Chemistry
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-6323