[comp.binaries.ibm.pc.d] Moderator bashing

cccstevn@dino (Steve Ansell) (02/01/91)

In article <3050@sixhub.UUCP> davidsen@sixhub.UUCP (bill davidsen) writes:
>ian@unipalm.uucp (Ian Phillipps) writes:
>
>>Much as I enjoy using GIF image viewers, I feel that at least three
>>postings of *shareware* image viewer in as many months (versions 27?, 28?
>>and now 292) is excessive. Does the moderator have shares in the publishers?
>
>  And when I don't update them every month or so people complain that
>there are fixes they don't have.
>
>  I have been holding several pieces of shareware of my own off the list
>for a year to avoid having anyone claim I was taking advantage of the
>group, now this. Along with being hassled by lawyers, insulted by
>authors when I don't move stuff fast enough, hassled by others because
>the volume is too high, tying up 150MB of my disk, two hours a day of my
>time, and about $30/month in phone bills, now I'm accused of taking
>paybacks.
>
>  Why should I do this when I can watch CNN? Good night.
>-- 

Bill,
   Please don't get discouraged because of one person's thoughtless comments.
There are others of us out here who think you are doing an exellent job as
moderator.  c.b.i.p. is one of my fovorite groups and I always look forward 
to new uploads.  In my opinion the more posted, the better and I have no
problem with putting up with posts that aren't usefull to me (these are 
obviously unavoidable).  How can someone complain about repeates when sometimes
days go by without new submissions :-).  So, keep them coming and, by all
means, post your own software.  I don't subscribe to the idea of self-
sacrifice, so go ahead and reap some rewards from your thankless work.  I
assume the person who wrote those comments doesn't remember the time that
this group spent un-moderated.  Since you have taken over, things have gone
smoothly and been well organized.  Keep up the good work.

						-Steven T. Ansell
						Computer Center Consultant
						Computing Services U.C.D.

mjf@cunixb.cc.columbia.edu (Michael J Flory) (02/02/91)

I agree wholeheartedly with Steve Ansell that Bill Davidsen is doing a
wonderful job moderating, and that we all owe him and the other moderators
gratitude for the enormous amount of time the task takes.  I rather apprecia-
ted having three viewers show up at once (or was Ian Phillipps complaining 
about repeat postings of the same viewer?).  I downloaded the three and will
give each a try.  -- Michael Flory (mjf@cunixb.cc.columbia.edu)

ian@unipalm.uucp (Ian Phillipps) (02/04/91)

chaz@chinet.chi.il.us (Charlie Kestner) writes:

>  I rarely see the complainers take on the job of "doer", so let's
>not have any more of this "wahhhhh...it didn't work...wahhhh...there's
>too many versions....wahhhh...there's not bug-fixes....wahhhh" kinds
>of things.

[Please see a separate posting apologising to Bill Davidsen]

As a point of information, I have made the following submissions to usenet:

- A pretty geometric doo-dah of no particular usefulness (posted to
  comp.sources.misc: free)

- An improved version of a port of unix "ed" (sources posted to c.s.m;
  binaries sent to a previous cpib moderator and never posted, as far
  as I know - free)

- A port of "perl" V3 to DOS. Patches mailed to Larry Wall at his
  request - I don't know whether his supported version is mine or some
  better one. Copyleft imposed by Larry.

- Bugfix and some improvements to the fdfmt program (patches submitted to
  author)

I we weren't at the wrong end of an expensive mail link from most submitters
to the network, I'd be happy to be a moderator.

As a user of many cbip programs, I accept them in the spirit in which they
are offered, which varies.

Ian