[net.followup] Nuclear Accidents and boiling water

tan@ihlpg.UUCP (Bill Tanenbaum) (07/04/86)

> In article <806@bu-cs.UUCP> bzs@bu-cs.UUCP writes:
> >Re: boiling removes radioactivity from water??
> >I think the idea of boiling water to remove radioactive contaminants
> >is preposterous (I'm curious as to the authenticity of the original
> >suggestion.)
> >The whole suggestion is absurd (it wasn't Kenneth's suggestion.)
> >	-Barry Shein, Boston University
> I was the original poster of this article.  I posted it to net.jokes as
> well so that everybody could have a good laugh at how stupid the British
> Embassy in Moscow was.  It was their suggestion.  Their reasoning was 
> that radioactivity was like something like cholera germs, and could be 
> killed off by boiling.  (Yes it's true).
> Paul Anderson.  The Bicycle Repairman.  (Vive la velorution!)
--------------
Actually, it's not totally preposterous.  If a radioactive gas was
dissolved in the water, boiling the water would cause it to bubble
off.

-- 
Bill Tanenbaum - AT&T Bell Labs - Naperville IL  ihnp4!ihlpg!tan

wcjanzen@watnot.UUCP (Craig Janzen) (07/07/86)

>> >Re: boiling removes radioactivity from water??
>> >I think the idea of boiling water to remove radioactive contaminants
>> >is preposterous (I'm curious as to the authenticity of the original
>> >suggestion.)

>> I was the original poster of this article.  I posted it to net.jokes as
>> well so that everybody could have a good laugh at how stupid the British
>> Embassy in Moscow was.  It was their suggestion.  Their reasoning was 
>> that radioactivity was like something like cholera germs, and could be 
>> killed off by boiling.  (Yes it's true).

>Actually, it's not totally preposterous.  If a radioactive gas was
>dissolved in the water, boiling the water would cause it to bubble
>off.

And then the water could be distilled leaving behind all the solid
radioactive waste.

timlee@bnrmtv.UUCP (Timothy Lee) (07/10/86)

> >> >Re: boiling removes radioactivity from water??
> >> >I think the idea of boiling water to remove radioactive contaminants
> >> >is preposterous (I'm curious as to the authenticity of the original
> >> >suggestion.)
> 
> >> I was the original poster of this article.  I posted it to net.jokes as
> >> well so that everybody could have a good laugh at how stupid the British
> >> Embassy in Moscow was.  It was their suggestion.  Their reasoning was 
> >> that radioactivity was like something like cholera germs, and could be 
> >> killed off by boiling.  (Yes it's true).
> 
> >Actually, it's not totally preposterous.  If a radioactive gas was
> >dissolved in the water, boiling the water would cause it to bubble
> >off.
> 
> And then the water could be distilled leaving behind all the solid
> radioactive waste.

Meanwhile, one is breathing all of that bubbled off radioactive gas...

hoffman@hdsvx1.UUCP (07/17/86)

Concerning the boiling of water to remove radioactivity,
Bill Tanenbaum - AT&T Bell Labs - Naperville IL writes:
> Actually, it's not totally preposterous.  If a radioactive gas was
> dissolved in the water, boiling the water would cause it to bubble
> off.

Where? Into my kitchen?!

I prefer my room deodorizers to be invisible, even with the lights off. :-)
-- 
 Richard Hoffman                | "If you take a starving dog from the street
 Schlumberger Well Services     | and make him prosperous, the dog will not
 hoffman%hdsvx1@slb-doll.csnet  | bite you.  This is the principle difference
 PO Box 2175, Houston, TX 77252 | between a dog and a man." -- M. TWAIN

franka@mmintl.UUCP (Frank Adams) (07/22/86)

In article <288@hdsvx1.UUCP> hoffman@hdsvx1.UUCP writes:
>Concerning the boiling of water to remove radioactivity,
>Bill Tanenbaum - AT&T Bell Labs - Naperville IL writes:
>> Actually, it's not totally preposterous.  If a radioactive gas was
>> dissolved in the water, boiling the water would cause it to bubble
>> off.
>
>Where? Into my kitchen?!

Better in the air, where you breathe some of it, than in the water, where
you drink all of it.

Frank Adams                           ihnp4!philabs!pwa-b!mmintl!franka
Multimate International    52 Oakland Ave North    E. Hartford, CT 06108