[comp.parallel] Butterfly Users long

allan@cpsc.UCalgary.CA (Jeff Allan) (02/20/89)

In article <4156@hubcap.UUCP> I wrote:
>I am interested in identifying BBN Butterfly sites and establishing a forum
>for discussing experiences, problems, etc.
>Anyone interested in participating in this exchange of information can either
>post their particulars to this newsgroup or email me directly.
>I will post a follow-up summary to this group if the response warrants.
>If anyone would prefer not to their particulars posted to the net should
>indicate so in their response.
>
>I'll get things started by telling you about our site.
>The University of Calgary has a Butterfly Plus with 12 nodes. 
>We use it for research in parallel processing and simulation.
>We've had for about a year now.

I received about a dozen replies representing about eight sites. 
These are summarized below, followed by a long listing of the original replies.

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Summary
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

Brian J Palmer
Bolt Beranek and Newman Inc., Cambridge MA
bpalmer%BBN.COM%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA

Scott Whitman (slim@cis.ohio-state.edu)
Ohio State Computer Science Department

Dick Peskin
Rutgers University
peskin%caip.rutgers.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA (R. L. Peskin)

Neil B. Cohen
BBN-ACI, Washington D.C.
"Neil B. Cohen" <uunet!BBN.COM!nbc>

Randy Michelsen
Los Alamos National Laboratory
rem%manihi%LANL.GOV%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA (Randy E. Michelsen)

David Kotz
Department of Computer Science, Duke University, Durham, NC 27706
decvax!duke!dfk

Karsten
Georgia Tech.
schwan@gatech.edu

Michael L. Scott
University of Rochester    (716) 275-7745
scott@cs.rochester.edu     scott%rochester@CSNET-RELAY
{decvax, allegra, cmcl2}!rochester!scott

Floyd Wofford
Ballistic Research Laboratory
floyd@smoke.brl.mil

Yiannis
Ohio State University
yiannis%cis.ohio-state.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA

David
BBN Advanced Computers, Inc., Cambridge MA
mailrus!yeager.bbn.com!djoslin@gatech.uucp

jr
BBN Systems and Technologies Corporation, Cambridge MA
jr@bbn.com or bbn!jr

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Full responces follow
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

>From bpalmer%BBN.COM%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Fri Jan 20 11:52:10 1989
To: allan@cpsc.ucalgary.ca
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
Newsgroups: comp.parallel
In-Reply-To: <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
Organization: Bolt Beranek and Newman Inc., Cambridge MA
Date: Fri, 20 Jan 89 11:17:02 -0500
From: bpalmer%BBN.COM%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
Status: RO

Hi,
 
I would also like to see a BBN Butterfly forum get started.  I work in BBN's
Newport,RI office where we've been working on a large simulation for the
last 3 years.  At present, we're using a 28 node Plus with 16 BVME's.
 
Brian J Palmer

>From slim%cis.ohio-state.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Fri Jan 20 13:33:41 1989
Date: Fri, 20 Jan 89 13:23:33 EST
From: slim%cis.ohio-state.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
Message-Id: <8901201823.AA20131@tut.cis.ohio-state.edu>
To: allan@cpsc.ucalgary.ca
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
Newsgroups: comp.parallel
In-Reply-To: <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
Organization: Ohio State Computer Science Department
Cc: 
Status: RO

 
Just thought you would want to include us on your list.  I'm at the
Ohio State University Computer Science Department and we have a Butterfly
GP1000 Running Mach.  We are doing research in operating systems, graphics,
and AI on the machine (it has 10 nodes).
 
You might talk with BBN for other sites but some others include:  Duke,
Rochester, and University of Maryland to name a few.
 
        Scott Whitman (slim@cis.ohio-state.edu)
--
 Scott Whitman, Graduate Research Assistant in Computer Graphics
 slim@cis.ohio-state.edu    or   ...!cbosgd!osu-cis!slim
The Ohio State University; 2036 Neil Ave. Columbus OH USA 43210-1277

>From peskin%caip.rutgers.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Fri Jan 20 16:19:29 1989
Date: Fri, 20 Jan 89 18:13:09 EST
From: peskin%caip.rutgers.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA (R. L. Peskin)
Message-Id: <8901202313.AA23429@caip.rutgers.edu>
To: allan@cpsc.ucalgary.ca
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
Keywords: Butterfly Sites, Users' group
In-Reply-To: USENET article <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
Status: RO

Rutgers Univ has a 32 node GP1000. Used for parallel computing
research.
--dick peskin <peskin@caip.rutgers.edu>

>From alberta!mnetor!uunet!BBN.COM!nbc Sun Jan 22 10:30:14 1989
Date:     Sat, 21 Jan 89 20:18:31 EST
From: "Neil B. Cohen" <uunet!BBN.COM!nbc>
To: alberta!calgary!allan@seismo.CSS.GOV
Subject:  Butterfly Users group
Status: RO

Jeff,

I work for BBN-ACI on the Butterfly in the Washington D.C. area. The
people at the Naval Research Lab (NRL) tried to start a local users
group this past summer. They had a few meetings, with some interesting
speakers - one of the speakers was Darrin West from U. Calgary.

You might be interested in contacting Steve Matney at NRL
about your user's group forum. His email address used to be
matney@nrl-css.arpa. If you can't get him, try Jeff Handy
(handy@nrl-css.arpa or handy@itd.nrl.navy.mil).

As a BBN employee, I tried to help Steve get a user's group
going, but at the same time, I believe that such a group should
be run by and for the customers - BBN will help where possible,
but we want to stay out of the way too.

If there is anything I can do for you - please let me know.

Neil B. Cohen (nbc)

PHONE:	703-848-4877
UUCP:	...{ihnp4, seismo}!bbn.com!nbc
DOMAIN:	nbc@bbn.com				Murphy was an optimist!

>From rem%manihi%LANL.GOV%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Mon Jan 23 08:33:37 1989
Date: Mon, 23 Jan 89 08:21:17 MST
From: rem%manihi%LANL.GOV%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA (Randy E. Michelsen)
Message-Id: <8901231521.AA00595@manihi.lanl.gov>
To: allan@cpsc.ucalgary.ca
Subject: Butterfly
Status: RO

Jeff --
 
We recently acquired a 6 node GP1000 for (parallel) simulation
research.  Are you associated with the TimeWarp activities (we have
some interest in that paradigm here)?
 
Thanks,
 
 Randy Michelsen
 Los Alamos National Laboratory
 505-667-0789
 

>From dfk%cs.duke.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Sun Jan 22 19:07:14 1989
Date: Sun, 22 Jan 89 20:48:05 EST
From: dfk%cs.duke.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
Message-Id: <8901230148.AA20344@romeo.cs.duke.edu>
To: allan@cpsc.UCalgary.CA
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
In-Reply-To: your article <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
News-Path: duke!mcnc!rutgers!mailrus!uflorida!gatech!hubcap!allan
Status: RO

> I am interested in identifying BBN Butterfly sites and establishing a forum
> for discussing experiences, problems, etc.
 
BBN used to support a mailing-list for Butterfly users. Check with
them to see if they still have such a thing. I don't think so.
 
We have a 32-processor GP1000, which just had the first real release
of Mach booted this weekend. We have beta-tested Mach for several
months.
 
In early 1987 we got a Butterfly 1 which was later upgraded to a
32-processor Butterfly Plus running Chrysalis 4.0.  However, this is
not used much and will soon merge with the above to make a 64-node
GP1000, whenever 64-node Mach is available.
 
We use the two for parallel Systems research and for VLSI simulation
research, and for graduate-level OS classes. We hope it will also be
used for scientific computing applications and research, but that is
starting slowly.
 
Include me, but I can't speak for any other users here.
 
David Kotz
Department of Computer Science, Duke University, Durham, NC 27706
ARPA:    dfk@cs.duke.edu
CSNET:    dfk@duke
UUCP:    decvax!duke!dfk

>From schwan%wayward%gatech.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Mon Jan 23 11:54:40 1989
Date: Mon, 23 Jan 89 13:35:13 EST
From: schwan%wayward%gatech.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA (Karsten Schwan)
Message-Id: <8901231835.AA01575@wayward.gatech.edu>
To: allan@cpsc.UCalgary.CA
Subject: Butterfly
Status: R

We are now getting a 32-node BBN Butterfly here at Georgia Tech.
I had a machine at my previous place of employment (Ohio State),
as well. In fact, there is a 12 node machine there still.
 
Karsten
schwan@gatech.edu

>From scott%cs.rochester.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Mon Jan 23 11:55:25 1989
Date: Mon, 23 Jan 89 09:39:54 EST
From: scott%cs.rochester.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
Message-Id: <8901231439.AA06398@sirius.cs.rochester.edu>
To: allan@cpsc.UCalgary.CA
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
Newsgroups: comp.parallel
In-Reply-To: <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
Organization: U of Rochester, CS Dept, Rochester, NY
Cc: 
Status: R

The University of Rochester got its first Butterfly, a 3-node Butterfly 1
with a discrete component switch in the fall of 1984.  In the summer of
1985 we purchased a 128-node machine, 8 spare nodes, and an extra 16-way
switch, which we configured as a 120-node machine and a 16-node machine.
In 1986 we upgraded the 16-node machine to the 68020 daughterboards.
In January of 1988 we upgraded the 3-node machine to be a Butterfly Plus.
Later that spring we sliced off one quarter of the switch of the 120-node
machine (leaving it with 96 nodes) and traded in the remaining nodes to
get a 24-node Plus.  So now we have a 96-node Butterfly 1, a 16-node
Butterfly 1 with daughterboards (and a VME adaptor), a 3-node Butterfly
Plus, and a 24-node Butterfly Plus.
 
Our work with the Butterfly 1's is documented in an article in last summer's
PPEALS conference.  The Pluses are being used primarily for operating systems
research, notably the Psyche multiprocessor O.S. project and the Platinum
testbed for experimentation with non-uniform access time memory management
issues.  Psyche is described in a paper at last summer's ICPP.  Platinum
is described in a Rochester TR.
--
Michael L. Scott
University of Rochester    (716) 275-7745
scott@cs.rochester.edu     scott%rochester@CSNET-RELAY
{decvax, allegra, cmcl2}!rochester!scott

>From floyd%BRL.MIL%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Tue Jan 24 09:32:47 1989
Date:     Tue, 24 Jan 89 10:34:24 EST
From: floyd%BRL.MIL%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
To: allan@cpsc.ucalgary.ca
Message-Id:  <8901241034.aa15989@SMOKE.BRL.MIL>
Status: R

To: allan@cpsc.UCalgary.CA
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
Newsgroups: comp.parallel
In-Reply-To: <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
Organization: Ballistic Research Laboratory
Cc:
 
 
  I am an employee of the U.S. Army Ballistic Research Laboratory.
We currently have a 16 node (processor) Butterfly.  It is idle
due to the lack of a file server.  We are in the process of
an upgrade to make this machine standalone.  I am not aware of
what stage the procurement process is in for the upgrade.  I
have reason to believe that I shall be the administrator and
a possible user for this machine.  It seems that I have been
tasked to do so.
  I am interested in your idea to keep the users in touch.
I currently do not have a project which I believe would
exploit the power of the architecture.  This is where I would
like to hear from some of the community.  I am an EE with
a major in signal processing.  I have been doing some recent
reading in neural networks.  It seems that most of the
implementations are on non-parallel machines (Connection not
included).  I am not sure I want to implement a NN on 15
68020s, but I have not seen much which points to parallel
architecture implementations.  This may be an absurd notion,
but I would be interesten if work is being done here.
  I would be interested in seeing some references to parallel
algorithm implementation of signal processing techniques
such as spectral analysis, adaptive filtering/beamforming
or some pattern recognition/image processing work.
  Until this upgrade is complete I would request that mention
of my interest be withheld.  With the upgrade I will be
fully involved with work on the machine.  As of this moment it
is vapor.
 
Floyd Wofford
floyd@smoke.brl.mil

>From yiannis%cis.ohio-state.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Tue Jan 24 19:37:54 1989
Date: Tue, 24 Jan 89 21:29:11 EST
From: yiannis%cis.ohio-state.edu%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
Message-Id: <8901250229.AA04341@junk.cis.ohio-state.edu>
To: allan@cpsc.ucalgary.ca
Subject: Bfly newsgroup
Status: R

We (at Ohio State University) have a Butterfly GP1000 with 10 nodes
running Mach O/S. We have designed and implemented a thread library which
originally was running under chrysalis O/S but now have been succesfully ported
under Mach (the Bfly Mach doesn't provide threads). We would be
definitely very intersted in a Bfly newsgroup (I am currently writing my
thesis on the thread library I mentioned above).
 
 
Yiannis


>From utai!gatech!mailrus!BBN.COM!yeager.bbn.com!djoslin Fri Jan 27 09:56:05 1989
To: BBN.COM!cpsc.UCalgary.CA!allan@mailrus.uucp
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
Newsgroups: comp.parallel
In-Reply-To: <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
Organization: BBN Advanced Computers, Inc., Cambridge MA
Cc: yeager.bbn.com!djoslin@mailrus.uucp
Date: 	Fri, 27 Jan 89 09:49:11 EST
From: mailrus!yeager.bbn.com!djoslin@gatech.uucp
Status: R

I'd be interested in what you find out.  
I work in the OS group doing Mach Unix on the Butterfly.

As you might assume, we have a number of Butterfly machines here,
and we all think that they are wonderful. :-)

David


>From jr%CHIPS.BBN.COM%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA Wed Feb  1 13:38:09 1989
To: allan@cpsc.ucalgary.ca
Subject: Re: BBN Butterfly Users
Newsgroups: comp.parallel
In-Reply-To: <4156@hubcap.UUCP>
Organization: BBN Systems and Technologies Corporation, Cambridge MA
Cc: 
Date: Wed, 1 Feb 89 14:30:45 EST
From: jr%CHIPS.BBN.COM%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
Sender: jr%CHIPS.BBN.COM%UcEdu.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA@Ucnet.UNCA.AdhocNet.CA
Status: RO

Have you gotten a response? If not, write back and I'll put you in
touch with someone at BBN ACI.
--
/jr
jr@bbn.com or bbn!jr

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
        Jeff Allan				University of Calgary
						Calgary, Alberta, Canada
	uunet!ubc-cs!calgary!allan		(403) 289-7877 (res)