[comp.sys.amiga.tech] Dont read this if you want to go to Disk Hell

chymes@zug.csmil.umich.edu (Charles Hymes) (12/14/89)

---------------------------------
DON'T use MRBackup of fish disk 270!!
From: chymes@zug.csmil.umich.edu (Charles Hymes)
Path: zug.csmil.umich.edu!chymes

Talk about a Trojen Horse.
A month ago, I had my first hard drive scramble. 
I didn't use a real backup program, so it took me a while to regain all my 
software. Now, I have completely re-installed  all that software, and I deside
that its time for a real backup program. I get MRbackup from ff270, and Backup
from ff258. I use MRbackup 'cause it was on a later disk, and looked much
more useful.
 Heh Heh Heh. MRBackup not only crashed every time I tried to use it, 5 times, 
IT GOD DAMM TRASHED MY FU*&*%$ HARD DISK!!!!!
Luckily, good old Matt came to the rescue and I got MOST of my stuff saved 
after 2 hours of backing up.
I used the disk-fixer wich came with my SCSI driver, and it supposedly 
"RESTORED" my file system. BUT I still cant write to the drive because 
even after rebooting, it wont validate.
How do  you fix a damaged (hard) disk so that it will be validated? Is there
 any way to fix a disk so that it will validate? I've got lots
of uncorrupted files. If I got a disk sector editor, coul I use it to solve
my problem? If I did fix it, how do you tell AmigaDOS that it's fixed?
I would be VERY greatful if someone could help me out of this mess. The
idea of re-installing all that software and data from floppy makes me sick.
Please!!
Thank You.
Charles Hymes




Mark Rinfret, if you see this,
 FLAME ON.... 
ARRRGHH!!!!! GRRRR!! :-( :-( :-( :-( :-( :-( 
 FLAME OFF... 
send me mail, some of the bugs I could identify, even if I didn't see the disk 
damage till it was to late.
C.H.

bevis@EE.ECN.PURDUE.EDU (Jeff Bevis) (12/15/89)

In article <1989Dec14.063253.29855@csmil.umich.edu>, chymes@csmil.umich.edu (Charles Hymes) writes:
>DON'T use MRBackup of fish disk 270!!

Why not?

> Heh Heh Heh. MRBackup not only crashed every time I tried to use it, 5 times, 
>IT GOD DAMM TRASHED MY FU*&*%$ HARD DISK!!!!!

Did you read the lengthy documentation file that came with it, first?

>Mark Rinfret, if you see this,
> FLAME ON.... 
>ARRRGHH!!!!! GRRRR!! :-( :-( :-( :-( :-( :-( 
> FLAME OFF... 

I can understand your excitement at the munging of your hard drive, but I
use MRBackup and have not had any trouble yet -- nothing like this.  I
suspect you are just not fully aware of the operation of MRBackup -- (I'm
not sure I am, really, either :-).  Give Mark a break;  his program's ok,
and I'M sure he'd be more than glad to help you with your problems if you'd
just ask... (he's really a nice guy).  However, since you posted this, I
imagine you'll be hearing from him here pretty soon anyway...


+--------------------------------+--------------------------------------------+
| Jeff Bevis 		         | "But I don't like spam!"		      |
| bevis@en.ecn.purdue.edu	 | 	     Give me Amiga or nothing at all. |
+--------------------------------+--------------------------------------------+

bmacintyre@watdragon.waterloo.edu (Blair MacIntyre) (12/17/89)

bevis@EE.ECN.PURDUE.EDU (Jeff Bevis) writes:
>chymes@csmil.umich.edu (Charles Hymes) writes:
>>DON'T use MRBackup of fish disk 270!!
>Why not?

Because ...
 
>> Heh Heh Heh. MRBackup not only crashed every time I tried to use it, 5 times, 
>>IT GOD DAMM TRASHED MY FU*&*%$ HARD DISK!!!!!
>
>I can understand your excitement at the munging of your hard drive, but I
>use MRBackup and have not had any trouble yet -- nothing like this.  I
>suspect you are just not fully aware of the operation of MRBackup

Well, I recently switched from Matt's Backup program to MrBackup for the
simple reason that I _love_ the technique used by MRBackup, that of 
creating a similar directory tree and compressing the files.  Makes for
much quicker restores of one of two files.

But, the program makes me nervous (ask my officemate:  I wouldn't let
him flip screens and use VLT while it was backing up! ) ... why?  
For the reasons expressed above:  it crashed a number of times.  They
were fairly consistent, too.  

- flipping screens with DMouse would eventually hang my machine when the
  MRBackup screen came up.  This has NEVER happened with DMouse before.

- Using the utilities sometimes caused it to crash.

I'm using the newest version that came across the net.

All in all, I like the program.  But, it seems to be a little flakey
in the "multitasking nicely" area!

Blair
-- 
-- Blair MacIntyre, Professional Leech on Society ( aka CS Graduate Student )
-- bmacintyre@{watcgl, watdragon, violet}.{waterloo.edu, UWaterloo.ca}
-- Date, verb: prearranged socializing with intent.