[comp.sys.handhelds] HP 41 battery indicator?

sjk@ut-emx (bob) (09/05/90)

Netters,
I have a question regarding an old HP calculator called the 41CX;
perhaps you remember it.  Anyway, I am running it with the
rechargeable battery pack, but am always left guessing when it
needs recharging (or I wait till it beeps, then quit whatever I'm
doing to set up the recharge.)  Is there any way I can find out how
much charge is left, so I can recharge it when it's low, but not
yet to the state where it'll beep at me?

Thanks,

Scot
sjk@astro.as.utexas.edu

lennartb@lne.kth.se (Lennart Boerjeson @ KTH/LNE, The Royal Inst. of Tech.) (09/12/90)

In article <36930@ut-emx>, sjk@ut-emx (bob) writes:
>
>
>
>Netters,
>I have a question regarding an old HP calculator called the 41CX;
>perhaps you remember it.  Anyway, I am running it with the
>rechargeable battery pack, but am always left guessing when it
>needs recharging (or I wait till it beeps, then quit whatever I'm
>doing to set up the recharge.)  Is there any way I can find out how
>much charge is left, so I can recharge it when it's low, but not
>yet to the state where it'll beep at me?
>
>Thanks,
>
>Scot
>sjk@astro.as.utexas.edu

No way. The only sensor available to you is the low battery indicator
(if I remember correctly you can sense it via a system flag). Why do
use rechargeable batteries? Do you use a card reader *extensively*?
I replaced my Ni-Cad pack with ordinary alkalii batteries
when I stopped using my card reader. MUCH longer life. If you have an
old 41 which still has the connector for the never-released battery eliminator
you can save battery life by using a home-built, external battery pack at
home.

!++
! Lennart Boerjeson, System Manager
! School of Electrical Engineering
! Royal Institute of Technology
! S-100 44 Stockholm, Sweden
! tel: int+46-8-7907814
! Internet: lennartb@lne.kth.se
!--

rrd@hpfinote.HP.COM (Ray Depew x2419) (09/12/90)

>I have a question regarding an old HP calculator called the 41CX;
>doing to set up the recharge.)  Is there any way I can find out how
>much charge is left, so I can recharge it when it's low, but not
>yet to the state where it'll beep at me?

Well, I've still got my 41CX, but I gave away the manuals and Wlodek's
masterpiece a while ago, so ....   There is a "Low Battery" system flag
on the 41.  It can be tested, but not set or cleared (by normal means,
anyway).  I think (corrections, please) that one system routine monitors
the battery and sets the flag, while another routine monitors the flag
status and turns on the BAT annunciator and/or the "LOW BATTERY" message.

Unfortunately, the battery check on the 41 is a binary check:  either it's
low or it isn't.  (Comparators are not as complicated as ADC's, I guess.)
Fortunately, when the annunciator comes on you still have plenty of 
runtime before you're REALLY in trouble.

>Thanks,
>Scot

Not what you wanted to hear, but you're welcome anyway.

Regards
Ray Depew
HP Colorado IC Division 
rrd@hpfitst1.hp.com
Just me shooting off my mouth....

mark@hpcpbla.HP.COM (Mark Simms) (09/19/90)

The problem with the low battery indicator on the HP-41 series
calculators is that it does not work well with NiCads.  These, by
their very nature, have a very stable voltage over most of their life
and then fail very quickly.  As such the low battery indication is
signaled with less useful life in the batteries than with alkaline
cells.  It is still better than nothing.  The most important thing is
that you can plug in the recharger and recharge the batteries whilst
the calculator is running and without removing the batteries.  This is
particularly important for Time Module users who don't want to reset
their clocks.

As for using alkaline cells, the NiCads are much cheaper in the long
run and do not waste raw materials.  They also cause considerably less
polution.  For users in the U.K. where N size cells are nearly
impossible to get hold of, NiCads are a must.

Mark Simms

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Opinions expressed are my own and are not intended to be an official
statement by Hewlett-Packard Company
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Name:         Mark Simms
Profession:   Software Engineer
Occupation:   Research and Development
Organization: Hewlett-Packard Computer Peripherals Division
Unix-mail:    mark%hpcpbla@hplb.hpl.hp.com
Address:      Filton Road, Bristol BS12 6QZ, United Kingdom
Phone:        +44-272-799910x22174
Fax:          +44-272-236091
----------------------------------------------------------------------

akcs.michaelv@hpcvbbs.UUCP (Michael VanLoon) (10/19/90)

The low power flag is #49.  The solution I found for dying NiCd's is to
have a set of alkaline N-cells handy for the "moment of truth" when the
BAT annunciator comes on.  Simply pop the alkalines in to get you through
the moment, until you can get home and recharge.  Then stick the
alkalines back in a safe spot until next time.  Alkaline batteries have a
shelf life of several years, so this should work well for many
drain/recharge cycles.  (I'm still using the original alkalines that came
with my 41CX 2-1/2 years ago for this purpose with no problems).

Michael V
ISU