[comp.periphs.printers] 24 pin wide carriage printer choic

crosenberg@cdp.UUCP (08/25/90)

I am interested in hearing from people who have had a lot of
experience with various brands of 24 pin wide carriage printers.
PC Magazine gives Editor's choice to the Olympia NP 136-24 and
the IBM Proprinter XL24E.  I am a little concerned about buying
the Olympia because I don't see it advertized very widely.  I
wonder if the IBM is over-priced just because of the brand name
although I am sure it is a good printer.  I saw a mail order
price of $689 for the IBM.  The earlier model proprinters were
real work horses.  I have had very good experience with Okidata
320's and I wonder if the Okidata 391 which is a 24 pin wide
carriage model is just as good as it less expensive sibling.
The NEC printers have also been recommended to me, but I don't
know what they have in a 24 pin wide carriage model.

The two features that I am most concerned about are jam-free
paper handling and good print quality.

Any help on this would be very much appreciated.

sreekanth@rgb.dec.com (Jon Sreekanth) (09/13/90)

In article <137600001@cdp>, crosenberg@cdp.UUCP writes...
> 
>I am interested in hearing from people who have had a lot of
>experience with various brands of 24 pin wide carriage printers.
>PC Magazine gives Editor's choice to the Olympia NP 136-24 and
>the IBM Proprinter XL24E.  I am a little concerned about buying
>the Olympia because I don't see it advertized very widely.  I

For what it's worth, I recently bought a Panasonic 1124. 360 dpi
and 24 pin , 11" wide carriage. I forget the speed now. I'd heard
good recommendations from several friends. More important, the
market seems to have decided in favor of Panasonic. I was at a 
'Ken Gordon PC Show' last weekend, and the two most carried brands 
of printers were the 1124 and 1624 (similar but 16" carriage). 

/ Jon Sreekanth

US Mail : J Sreekanth, 79 Apsley Street, Apt #7, Hudson, MA 01749
          Digital Equipment Corp., 77 Reed Road, HLO2-1/J12, Hudson, MA 01749
email   : sreekanth@rgb.dec.com
Voice   : 508-562-3358 eves, 508-568-7195 work

rrd@hpfinote.HP.COM (Ray Depew x2419) (09/14/90)

For what it's worth, check out the Hewlett-Packard RuggedWriter.  It's 
the nicest 24-pin machine I've seen yet (but of course I'm prejudiced :-)

I can't speak as to price, but I should warn you that this is an
industrial-strength printer and may be more expensive than you
are willing to pay.  But you owe it to yourself to have a look at it...

Regards
Ray Depew
HP Colorado IC Division 
rrd@hpfitst1.hp.com