[comp.sys.proteon] ping pong routing

jrr@SCAMP.CONCERT.NET (Joe Ragland) (12/03/89)

To someone at Proteon that might like to reply:

128.167.9.1 is a serial line interface on the UT-Knoxville SURAnet
p4200 connected to 128.167.9.2 serial line interface on the Univ.
of Kentucky p4200.  My question is why does p4200 routing zip
through UT-Knoxville and do a bank shot off UKY and back to
UTK when I attempt to route to the UTK address as follows?

Script started on Sat Dec  2 17:30:28 1989
scamp# tracerouter  128.167.9.1
traceroute to 128.167.9.1 (128.167.9.1), 30 hops max, 40 byte packets
 1  * suranet-gw.concert.net (128.109.193.3)  18 ms  19 ms
 2  clemson-u.sura.net (128.167.5.2)  56 ms  55 ms  222 ms
 3  georgia-tech.sura.net (128.167.6.2)  2806 ms  320 ms  193 ms
 4  alabama-birmingham-u.sura.net (128.167.7.2)  202 ms  112 ms  113 ms
 5  u-tennessee.sura.net (128.167.8.2)  469 ms  4981 ms  150 ms
 6  u-kentucky.sura.net (128.167.9.2)  171 ms  2654 ms  220 ms
 7  u-tennessee.sura.net (128.167.9.1)  263 ms  373 ms  351 ms
scamp# exit
scamp# 
script done on Sat Dec  2 17:31:10 1989

I agree that one would not follow this path in routing to hosts at
UTK but this result is at least interesting for us folk that like
to use SNMP to check interfaces and other matters of connectivity
and network performance.  Seems routing to any p4200 serial line
address on all p4200s in SURAnet behaves similarily.

The erratic response times are characteristic of the present overloaded
SURAnet circuits outside of the SURAnet/NSFnet gateway congestion at
UMD.

Joe Ragland