[comp.protocols.tcp-ip.ibmpc] PC --> Appletalk --> FastPath?

nsabh@atr-2s.atr.hac.com (04/30/91)

Has anyone tried PC using NCSA Telnet to go
through Appletalk to the FastPath gateway using
the clarkson driver localtalk? I am having
trouble doing it and could use some advice.

Thanks.

_________________________________             _____________________
|Nael Sabha			|            / ____________________
|Software Engineering Division	|  ---      / /
|Hughes Aircraft Co.		| --- \    / / 
|Ground Systems Group,		|    \ \  / / 
|(nsabh%atr-2s@hac2arpa.hac.com)|     \ \/ / 
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^      \/\/ 

IJAH400@INDYVAX.IUPUI.EDU ("James A. Harvey") (05/01/91)

In article <14613@hacgate.UUCP>, Nael Sabha <nsabh@atr-2s.hac.com> asks:
  >Has anyone tried PC using NCSA Telnet to go
  >through Appletalk to the FastPath gateway using
  >the clarkson driver localtalk? I am having
  >trouble doing it and could use some advice.
  >
  >Thanks.

Read the file LOCALTLK.NOT from the packet driver distribution carefully.
The Clarkson LocalTalk packet driver is a class 5 (AppleTalk) driver only.
Many TCP/IP software packages for the PC, including NCSA Telnet and Clarkson's
CUTCP, do not support any classes other than class 1 (DIX Ethernet).  There's
a modified version of Phil Karn's ka9q mentioned in LOCALTLK.NOT that supports
class 5, but being at a commercial site, you'd have to arrange for permission
to use it.

     - Jim

James Harvey, IUPUI Computing Services, IJAH400@IUPUI.EDU or HARVEY@INDIANA.EDU

rmf@media.uucp (Roger Fujii) (05/02/91)

IJAH400@INDYVAX.IUPUI.EDU ("James A. Harvey") writes:

>In article <14613@hacgate.UUCP>, Nael Sabha <nsabh@atr-2s.hac.com> asks:
>  >Has anyone tried PC using NCSA Telnet to go
>  >through Appletalk to the FastPath gateway using
>  >the clarkson driver localtalk? I am having
>  >trouble doing it and could use some advice.
>  >
>  >Thanks.

>Read the file LOCALTLK.NOT from the packet driver distribution carefully.
>The Clarkson LocalTalk packet driver is a class 5 (AppleTalk) driver only.
>Many TCP/IP software packages for the PC, including NCSA Telnet and Clarkson's
>CUTCP, do not support any classes other than class 1 (DIX Ethernet).  There's
>a modified version of Phil Karn's ka9q mentioned in LOCALTLK.NOT that supports
>class 5, but being at a commercial site, you'd have to arrange for permission
>to use it.

I modified the localtlk.com & pcroute2.1 so that the it would *appear* to be
a class 1 driver (of sorts) [ can you say hyper-hack?].   This has the
advantage of being compatible with all these class 1 applications
(have tested it with NCSA & FTP Software's pctcp) and it works OK.

There are several disadvantages:
	1) localtlk packets cannot be > 590 bytes, and since the drivers
	won't breakup/reconstruct packets, any IP packets > 580 or so gets
	dropped (still ok so long as you can specify the MTU in the application)
	2) It is incompatible with other IP-encapsulated-Appletalk applications.
	3) The dynamic IP allocation is really sick - this is due to the way
	pcroute cached the net address.

If there is sufficient interest, I'll pretty up the changes and send it out.

--
Roger Fujii - Media Cybernetics		Phone: (301)495-3305
Internet: rmf%media@uunet.uu.net 	UUCP: {uunet,hqda-ai}!media!rmf